In Cuba — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

the old monstrous god of bodkin and thimble

broke open till all was out I saw no paper question it

as silver as music the water here

we find the town beside the fort a contingency unsettled in sand

news here in Cuba signifies little but to say that something comes

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Cuba arrives in this poem last, and almost by accident. The title promises a place, but the first lines are about a sewing god. Only in the final couplet does the poem say "here in Cuba", and by then the speaker has already pieced the place together from scraps: a monstrous deity, a burst seam, a stretch of shining water, a town beside a fort. The central idea seems to be that a place can be known in fragments, and that the poem's own meaning is, like the island's "news", something that approaches without ever fully landing.

The opening image is strange and tactile: "the old monstrous god / of bodkin and thimble". A bodkin is a blunt needle for threading, and the word has also meant a dagger, so even this homely tool carries a hint of menace. A god of needlework recalls the old stories of fate being spun and stitched, though the poem never says so. What follows is a rupture: the god "broke open till all was out", as if a stitched thing split along its seams and spilled its contents. Then comes a line that can be read two ways: "I saw no paper question it". Either the speaker saw no paper, or nothing written ever challenged what happened. Both readings suggest a world where events go unrecorded and unquestioned. That idea quietly sets up the word "news" a few lines later.

The third couplet turns from myth to sensation: "as silver as music / the water here". The simile arrives before the thing it describes, so we hear "silver as music" before we learn it belongs to water. Mixing sight and sound in this way, silver for the eye and music for the ear, makes the water feel almost too bright to pin down. The sibilance in "silver", "music" and "here" gives the line a hush that matches its subject.

The fourth couplet brings in human structures, and the poem gets slightly colder. "We find the town beside the fort" has the plainness of a traveller's report, and the fort suggests defence or authority standing guard over the settlement. But the town is "a contingency unsettled in sand". "Contingency" means something that depends on chance, a possibility rather than a certainty. "Unsettled" plays on the idea of a settlement, so the town is both a place people have settled and one that cannot settle. Sand, the least stable ground imaginable, finishes the thought.

Formally, the poem is five unrhymed couplets, and each pair tends to hold one image. The lines are short and uneven, between five and eight syllables or so, with no regular beat. That looseness lets the sentences break at awkward points. "Broke open till all was out" spills over its line ending, the way its subject spills. Rhyme is absent, but sound still binds the poem: the hard b, d and k of "bodkin" against the soft, humming "thimble", or the dense t and s of "contingency unsettled in sand". The word "here" appears twice in the last half of the poem, as though the speaker keeps trying to anchor himself and keeps failing to say what "here" actually contains.

The ending is the most telling. "News here in Cuba signifies little / but to say that something comes." The sentence deflates its own subject. News usually delivers content, but here it signifies only arrival, with no detail about what is arriving. Coming after the unrecorded rupture of the opening and the shifting sand of the town, this reads as the poem's quiet thesis: in this place, events are felt before they are explained. The poem simply stops on the verb "comes", with no object and no resolution.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it makes us do what its speaker does. We receive a god, a sound, a fort and a rumor without being told how they connect, and we have to decide whether the connections matter or whether the gaps are the point. It is a good poem for students because it shows that meaning can come from tone, image and omission as much as from statement. It leaves us with a sense of waiting that the final lines both name and refuse to relieve.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss