Collector — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

her extravagant collection of antiquities— married to a bastard

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Nine words, no finite verb, and a whole household comes into view. Dave Bonta's "Collector" is built from two fragments, and the work of joining them falls to a single dash at the end of the second line. The first fragment describes a woman: "her extravagant / collection of antiquities." The second delivers a judgment: "married to a bastard." The poem never says how the two are connected, and that silence is what makes it interesting.

The most natural reading is that the collecting is a consolation. A woman who is unhappily married fills her life, and perhaps her rooms, with old and beautiful things. "Extravagant" supports this. It describes spending, but it also suggests excess, as if the collection were too large to be only a hobby. The word may be the speaker's mild disapproval, or an observation that she needs more than most people do. The dash then works like a quiet "because," or perhaps "while." We are left to choose between cause and coincidence.

The poem's sounds support that tension. The first two lines are long and Latinate: "extravagant," "collection," "antiquities." They are the language of catalogues and auction houses, polite and a little grand. "Antiquities" is the longest word in the poem, four syllables that stretch the line out. Then the last line drops to blunt, Anglo-Saxon words, and "bastard" lands on the final beat with its hard b and its clipped *-st-d* ending. The change in register is the whole joke, and the whole sting. We move from a refined vocabulary to a curse, and the curse is the last thing we hear. The *m* of "married" and the *b* of "bastard" also tie the line together, as if the marriage and the insult were already joined in the mouth.

The poem uses no rhyme, and its rhythm is loose. The lines run to roughly five, eight and six syllables, which sits close to the shape of a haiku but does not follow its count. Its subject is human behaviour rather than nature, and there is no seasonal image, so it reads more like a senryu, the short form that deals in people and their foibles. This makes it feel overheard, like a remark passed between two guests at a party. That impression matters, because the tone is hard to pin down. The speaker might be sympathetic, gossipy or sneering, and the poem gives no stage direction. The only evaluative word in it is "bastard," and it is unclear whose voice it belongs to.

That word is worth a closer look, because it carries more than one meaning. As an insult it is crude and direct. But its older sense, a child born outside marriage, links it to questions of origin, and origin is the central concern of antiquities. Collectors care about provenance, about whether an object is genuine or a fake. Placed beside that vocabulary, "bastard" hints that the husband may be the fraud in the house, the one thing in her life whose origins she should have checked. The title adds another possibility. "Collector" is singular and unqualified, so it can name the woman, but it could also point at the husband, who might have acquired a wife the way she acquires objects. The text does not insist on this reading, but it allows it.

Her possessions are also all old. Antiquities have survived because someone preserved them, and they are valued for lasting where other things did not. Set against a marriage that sounds like a disappointment, they suggest a longing for things that endure, or at least for things that do not talk back.

What gives the poem its force is how much it leaves out. There is no scene, no quarrel and no description of the husband beyond one word. A reader has to assemble the story, and that act of assembling is the poem's real subject. In three lines Bonta shows how a small form can suggest a whole life, mainly through the choice of what comes first, what comes last, and where the dash falls between them.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss