Suicidal tendencies — Poem analysis

dead things lodging in the garden grown out of order

a desire to be gone which I am sorry for

like a sign in the wind dancing with no will

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six short lines, no capital letters, no punctuation, and the poem still holds a whole bleak interior. The title is clinical. "Tendencies" sounds like a line from case notes. The poem itself drops that vocabulary and offers a garden, a sign and a bit of wind. Its central idea is that suicidal feeling can be a drift rather than a dramatic decision, a passive, shameful pull that the speaker apologises for even while describing it.

The first couplet sets the scene. "Dead things lodging" is an odd, precise phrase. To lodge is to be a boarder, an unwanted tenant who has overstayed, but it also means to be stuck, like something caught in the throat. Either way, the dead things are not gone. They are housed. The second line, "in the garden grown out of order", is the longest in the poem, and it sprawls the way an untended garden does. "Out of order" is a pun. A garden can lose its order by growing wild, but "out of order" is also what we say of a broken machine. The poem never says the garden is the speaker's mind, and judging by the imagery that is only an inference, but the pull of that reading is strong. Notice, too, that the grammar has no main verb. "Lodging" and "grown" are participles, so nobody does anything and no one is blamed. The mess simply exists.

A person finally appears in the second couplet, and only here. "A desire to be gone" is a surprisingly formal, cool way to put it. The poet chooses "desire" over "wish" or "want", and "gone" is a soft euphemism, as if the speaker were leaving a room. The poem never uses a harsher word. Then comes "which I am sorry for", the only place the word "I" is used. The phrase can be read two ways. The speaker may be apologising for the desire, perhaps to the people it would hurt. Or the speaker may feel sorry for it, in the sense of pity. The line also ends on the preposition "for", which leans toward an object that never arrives. We are never told who the apology is owed to, so it hangs in the white space.

The last couplet turns to a simile: "like a sign in the wind / dancing with no will". A sign is made to say something or point somewhere, yet this one is only pushed about. "Dancing" is a jaunty word for helplessness, and the clash is unsettling. "No will" is the most loaded phrase in the poem. It means no willpower, no agency, but it is hard not to hear the other meaning, the document a person leaves behind after death. The word "tendencies" from the title also fits here, since a tendency is a leaning, and a sign in the wind leans wherever it is blown. One possible reading is that the desire to be gone lacks the force to act, and that wanting something is not the same as deciding on it. The poem does not promise this, but the image allows it.

The sound of the poem supports its quiet. The lines are short, from four to eight syllables, and unrhymed, so nothing clicks shut with a neat chime. Instead, sounds recur softly. The d of "dead", "garden", "order", "desire" and "dancing" runs through the text like a low drumbeat. The w of "which", "wind" and "will" gathers in the final lines, and the short i in "lodging", "in", "wind" and "will" gives the ending a thin, breathy sound. Each couplet also breaks mid-thought, so the second line trails off rather than concluding.

The poem's significance lies in this restraint. It does not glamorise the feeling or explain it, and it does not rescue the speaker with a hopeful last line. It records an unspectacular, unheroic state, in which the garden is untidy, the wish is embarrassing and the sign keeps swinging. By making room for shame and apology as part of the experience, it tells the truth about how such feelings can seem from the inside. In just thirty-odd words, it shows how much a poem can say by saying very little.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Sensei

My teacher resembles a flightless bird: the sky, to him, is an open book written in a foreign tongue, his enormous eyes are no bigger
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss
DreamyDave Bonta

Deconversion

Ice is a house I could not stay in, the answer to a tune I never hear. Tell me how I promise forever