Complementarity — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

ice and water exchange days like a parliament of one

doubt will provide a new home for that which I believe is true

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four lines, two sentences, no punctuation and hardly a capital letter: Dave Bonta's "Complementarity" looks like something you could read in a single breath, yet it keeps turning over in your head afterwards. Its subject is how opposites that seem to cancel each other out can share one existence. More daringly, it suggests that belief and doubt might do the same.

The title carries a lot of weight. "Complementarity" is best known as a term from physics, where it describes how something, light being the classic case, can need two apparently incompatible descriptions before it is fully understood. The poem never explains the word. It offers two examples instead, one from the physical world and one from the mind, and lets them shed light on each other.

The first couplet begins with a strange, lovely verb: "ice and water exchange days." To exchange is to swap places or trade shifts, so the line suggests a freeze and a thaw taking turns, perhaps from night to afternoon or from one season to the next. Neither wins. The next line gives the paradox its name: "like a parliament of one." A parliament is by definition a gathering of many voices, and the word itself comes from the French for "to speak." A parliament of one is a contradiction, and yet it fits. Ice and water are the same substance in two states, a single body arguing with itself and taking turns to hold the floor. There may even be a pun in "days," since parliaments sit on particular days. The simile is slightly comic. It sets the grand cycles of nature beside the dry business of debate and procedure.

The second couplet turns from the world to the speaker, and "I" appears for the first time. "doubt will provide a new home" shifts to the future tense, and the confident "will" is quietly ironic, because what it promises is doubt. The vocabulary is domestic: "provide" and "home" cast doubt as a host or landlord rather than an intruder. Belief is not demolished here, only rehoused. Read alongside the first couplet, the poem seems to say that belief and doubt are like ice and water, two states of one mind. If so, a belief that has passed through doubt is a little like water, more fluid and easier to carry, while an unquestioned one is closer to ice. That is an inference, but the structure of the poem invites it.

The last line, "for that which I believe is true," is deliberately stiff. "That which" sounds like the language of statutes, which continues the parliamentary mood. The doubled phrase "believe is true" also admits a gap between believing something and its being so. The speaker does not claim "that which is true." Even the grammar has a little doubt built into it.

The poem's sound and shape support this. There is no rhyme, and the couplets are not tied together by chime or by any linking word such as "so" or "likewise." Three of the lines run to seven syllables, and the final one stretches to eight. That small overflow means the poem ends on a slightly unsettled note, like a thought that has not quite finished arranging itself. Long "i" sounds thread through it in "ice," "like," "provide" and "I," and the near-echo of "ice" and "I" quietly sets the frozen thing beside the believing self. The lack of punctuation means the leap between the two couplets is silent. The reader has to make the connection, and that gap is where the complementarity happens.

The poem is worth reading because it argues by arrangement rather than by assertion. It does not say that doubt and belief need each other. It places a physical image and a mental one side by side, refusing both to merge them and to set them against each other, and lets you feel how they fit. In about thirty words it also shows an attitude, an intellectual humility that treats doubt as something that keeps convictions alive rather than a threat to them. For students it is a useful example of how much a short poem can do with one odd verb, one impossible phrase and one well-placed silence.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss