Besieged — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

time and fear devour us

which God is glad now to play at cards

like a night made of paper I bled ink

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Fourteen or so words are enough for Dave Bonta's "Besieged" to build a whole predicament: a speaker under attack from forces that cannot be fought, a God who isn't paying attention, and a single act of resistance that looks a lot like surrender. The title sets the scene. A siege is a particular kind of violence. It is mostly waiting, with the walls closing in slowly and the supplies running down. The poem's first line makes the besiegers abstract: "time and fear devour us." Neither can be shot at or negotiated with. The verb "devour" turns them into animals, and the plural "us" widens the speaker's trouble into a shared one.

The middle stanza is the strangest and the most unsettling. "which God is glad now / to play at cards" can be read in at least two ways. "Which" might be a question: which God is glad to play cards while we are eaten alive? Or it might point back at the whole situation, so that the siege is something God is pleased to gamble with. Either way, the divine figure is not a protector but a bored onlooker. Cards are what people play to pass the time, which fits the idea of a siege as long waiting, and they are also a game of chance, so human lives become stakes in somebody else's amusement. The little word "now" adds a bitter edge. It suggests God has only just found this pastime, or that the pleasure comes at exactly the wrong moment. The alliteration of "God is glad" makes the line pleasantly smooth, and that smoothness is part of the cruelty.

The last stanza turns from the cosmic to the bodily and the literary. "like a night made of paper / I bled ink." The simile is odd enough to linger over. Paper is thin and easily torn, so a night made of it is a night with no real depth, a darkness that is only a surface. It also quietly links back to the cards, which are made of paper too. The universe God plays with and the page the speaker writes on begin to look like the same flimsy material. The speaker's answer to the siege is to bleed, but what comes out is ink. A wound becomes writing. The line can be read as the cost of making art, or as a suggestion that when everything is paper, even blood turns into text. The poem doesn't say whether this is a defeat or a kind of dignity, and it is stronger for leaving that open.

The form carries the same tension. There is no rhyme, no punctuation, and no capital letters except for "God" and "I", which are the two figures facing each other across the poem. Without full stops, the first stanza hangs open, as though the devouring never finishes. The lines are short, and the poem tightens as it goes. The stresses in "time and fear devour us" fall on heavy, plain words, and the closing line, "I bled ink", is three monosyllables in a row, each of them weighted. It lands like a final thud, or a drop falling onto a page. The verb tenses shift as well. "Devour" is present, an ongoing threat, while "bled" is past, which suggests the poem itself is the leftover evidence of something already done.

What makes the poem significant is how much it does without explaining itself. It offers no comfort, no argument with God, and no neat moral. It sets an image of helpless waiting beside an image of creative sacrifice and lets the reader feel how they connect. For a student reader it is also a good lesson in compression. Each word carries pressure, and the most important meanings sit in the gaps between the stanzas. The poem leaves you with an uncomfortable idea: when time and fear close in and heaven seems indifferent, writing may be the one thing the besieged can still do, even if it costs them something real.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.