Solipsist — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

my taste is for madness like a verse I never understand enough

I expect to find each child gone to be born

and I fall into neglect ward of a poisoned well

all my prayers lying in an indifferent box

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A solipsist is someone who can be certain of only one mind: their own. It sounds like a daring idea, the kind students argue about for fun. Dave Bonta's eight-line poem treats it as a condition to be lived in, and the living turns out to be bleak. Across four couplets the speaker moves from appetite to expectation, then to collapse, then to something close to silence. The title explains why. If nobody else is certainly there, nobody is listening.

The opening couplet sets up a strange comparison: "my taste is for madness / like a verse I never understand enough." "Taste" suggests something chosen, even relished, but the simile pulls it toward poetry, and toward a reader who keeps returning to a verse because understanding never quite arrives. "Never … enough" holds a small paradox. The speaker wants more understanding and is also drawn to whatever resists it. The poem is a short, difficult poem describing the pull of difficult poems. Madness and solipsism sit close together here, since both describe a mind sealed inside its own logic.

The second couplet is the oddest: "I expect to find each child / gone to be born." Normally a child is found after birth. Here every child has already left, and leaving is the way to be born. The phrasing echoes everyday idioms like "gone to bed" or "gone to seed" and bends them until they stop making ordinary sense. One reading, offered as an inference, is that this is how the solipsist sees other people. They are never quite present, always arriving from somewhere he cannot reach. The verb "expect" matters too, because he has already predicted the absence.

Then comes the fall. "And I fall into neglect / ward of a poisoned well." The word "fall" next to "well" gives a physical picture, a drop down a shaft. The word "ward" works two ways, as a minor in someone's care and as a room in a hospital, so the speaker is both a dependent child and a patient. The children who were missing in the previous stanza are replaced by one neglected child, the speaker himself. His guardian is a poisoned well, a source of nourishment that has itself gone bad. The phrase also recalls "poisoning the well," the argumentative trick of discrediting a source in advance so that nothing it says can be trusted. It is tempting to read this as the solipsist's own method, spoiling every outside source before it can reach him. The poem never says so, but the wordplay invites it.

The last couplet is the quietest: "all my prayers lying / in an indifferent box." The line break leaves "lying" hanging, so the prayers are both resting and perhaps untrue. "Indifferent" is a borrowed feeling, since a box cannot care. The word really belongs to whatever the prayers were addressed to, and the box stands in for it. The box could be a coffin, a letterbox or a collection box, and the poem does not choose. That vagueness keeps the image cold and unreadable. The emotional centre of the poem is that a true solipsist would have no one to pray to, yet this speaker prays anyway and finds the philosophy confirmed by the silence.

The form supports all this. There is no end rhyme and no punctuation, and only the pronoun "I" gets a capital, which ironically makes the self the one thing that stands out. The lines are short and loosely three-stressed, with "gone to be born" shrinking to four syllables, almost a whisper. The first couplet stretches into a long, slightly clumsy second line, as if the speaker is still reaching for understanding. Quiet sound-links hold the poem together: "expect" and "neglect" share an ending and bracket the second and third couplets, while "enough" and "indifferent" share an f-sound that ties the last line back to the first stanza. Because nothing is punctuated, each couplet leans into the next, and the "and" before "I fall" makes the collapse feel like a natural consequence rather than a shock.

The poem matters because of how little space it needs to turn an abstract position into a feeling. Solipsism usually appears as an argument, but here it is loneliness, and the poem gives no consolation and no answer from the box.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss