Sartorial — Poem analysis

I put on my best black trimmed with black silk on velvet gown

but O if I could have found my heart that blessed crumb

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Getting dressed is the last private thing we do before facing other people, and Dave Bonta's "Sartorial" is built around that small act. In five short lines a speaker puts on "my best black", wording that suggests mourning or some formal, solemn occasion. Then, with the outfit complete, the speaker admits that the one thing needed is missing: the heart. The central idea is a gap between outward preparation and inner feeling. The costume is perfect, but the person wearing it cannot find the part of themselves that is supposed to feel.

The first stanza is all surface and texture. "Black" appears twice in three lines, and the second time it is "trimmed with black", so the colour trims itself in a closed loop with no contrast to break it. The phrase "silk on velvet gown" adds richness without adding relief. The two fabrics are layered, silk over velvet, in a way that makes the gown sound heavy, expensive and carefully chosen. Even the word "best" matters. It implies effort, ceremony and wanting to do the occasion justice. The sentence is also grammatically complete and calm, as orderly as the dressing it describes. Nothing seems wrong yet.

The second stanza breaks that order. "But O" is an old-fashioned, almost spoken gasp, and it changes the register at once, from description to confession. The poem never finishes the thought it starts, because "if I could have found my heart" has no main clause to complete it. We do not hear what would have happened if the heart had turned up, so the sentence trails off the way a wish does. The tense also matters. "Could have found" is already past, which suggests the search is over and failed. The poem is free verse with no rhyme, but the line lengths still do work. The lines run six, three and five syllables, then swell to nine for the longing line, then drop to the shortest line of all. The poem builds toward the wish and then shrinks.

That last line, "that blessed crumb", is where the poem becomes memorable. Calling the heart a crumb makes it tiny, a leftover, the sort of thing that falls into the folds of a gown and cannot be picked out again. It is a surprising, almost domestic image for the heart, and it contrasts sharply with the grand velvet and silk. The gown is large and the heart is small. "Blessed" can be read two ways. It may carry a religious echo, since the crumb of bread has long been associated with ritual and consecration, though that is an inference from the word rather than anything the poem states. It may also be a tired, half-exasperated "blessed thing", the way someone speaks about a lost key. Both readings fit, and the mix of reverence and irritation feels true to how people talk about grief. There is a sound link as well. "Best black" and "blessed crumb" share their hard *b* and their clipped endings, so the costume and the lost heart echo each other across the gap between the stanzas.

The title adds a final layer of irony. "Sartorial" is a precise, slightly fussy word, the language of tailors and fashion columns, and it is a cool label for a poem about emotional absence. It frames the experience as a matter of clothes, which is how the speaker seems to cope: by concentrating on what can be controlled and put on. The poem never says who or what is being mourned, or whether anyone has died at all. That silence is part of its effect, because the missing heart could belong to any loss.

The poem's significance lies in how much it leaves out. In about twenty words it shows that grief is not always loud or displayed. Sometimes it is a numbness that sits inside a flawless outfit. The poem does not describe the feeling directly. It gives us a gown, a gasp and a crumb, and trusts us to understand what is missing.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Painted Trillium

Trillium undulatum Painted lady, late riser, you rush out of the ground, get pollinated on the fly
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Initiation

Let him continue in the ground, he who is now dead, where all things hurry—
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss