State of emergency — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

I have cut myself much from the bluntness of the razor

here where a boat must not drink the water

here was the flagmaker here was the discourse of the corn

like a lost bad government playing at cards

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dave Bonta's "State of emergency" never describes an emergency. A title like that promises sirens, decrees, a country holding its breath. What the poem delivers is eight lines of wounds, vanished trades and a government that has wandered off to play cards. It is built from fragments, and the gaps between them carry most of the meaning. The central idea seems to be that a crisis is felt less as a single event than as a loss of connection, between body and world, people and their work, rulers and the ruled.

The first couplet sets the unease. "I have cut myself much / from the bluntness of the razor" is slightly wrong as English, and the wrongness matters. A blunt razor ought to be the safer one, yet here bluntness is the cause of the damage, which fits the way dull blades tug and tear rather than slice. The line break also lets "cut myself much" stand alone, so it can be read as a self-inflicted wound, or, with "from" attached, as being cut off from much. The speaker is hurt and severed at once. The hard consonants of "bluntness" make the sentence feel blunt too.

Then the poem leaves the body for a place. "Here where a boat / must not drink the water" carries a quiet paradox. A boat exists to be on water, yet it is forbidden to "drink" it, which in boat terms means taking it in and sinking. "Must not" also sounds like a regulation, the language of emergency rules, so the line reads as both a physical warning and a command. Like the razor, the boat is a tool turned against its own purpose.

The word "here" then repeats three times in the next lines, and the tense shifts: "here was the flagmaker / here was the discourse of the corn." The repetition works like someone pointing at a map or at ruins. The past tense turns the poem into an inventory of what is gone. The pairing is unusual. A flagmaker belongs to the world of nations and symbols, while "the discourse of the corn" belongs to fields. "Discourse" is a formal, even political word, and giving it to corn is a lovely stroke of personification. It could mean the dry rustle of leaves in wind, or a whole farming community talking, and either way it suggests a place where even crops had a voice. Flag and field, state and soil, are both said to have been here, and neither is now.

The last couplet is the strangest: "like a lost bad government / playing at cards." It opens with "like," but the poem has no clear subject for the simile to compare. It hangs loose, which suits a poem about things coming unmoored. Each word also bends. "Lost" can mean misplaced, defeated or morally adrift, and "bad" is a flat, almost childish adjective that sounds more like a verdict than a description. "Playing at" cards suggests pretending, and makes the government idle and frivolous while the boat, the corn and the speaker's skin pay the cost. Cards also imply chance and stakes, with other people's lives as the chips.

Formally the poem is four unrhymed couplets, in free verse with no punctuation at all and only the pronoun "I" capitalised. Without commas or full stops the lines can slide into one another, and the reader has to decide where one thought ends and the next begins. The sound is held together by hard consonants instead of rhyme: "bluntness," "boat," "bad," and then "cut," "corn," "discourse," "cards." The harshness echoes the razor from the opening.

The poem's significance lies in this restraint. Nothing in the text pins it to a particular country or crisis, so the emergency becomes a condition rather than a news story. The movement runs from "I" to "here" to "government," from skin to landscape to power, and each step takes the reader further from anything personal. By the end the wound has no obvious cause and no one seems to be in charge. A state of emergency, the poem suggests, is what it feels like when the language of order, with its flags, rules and discourse, no longer fits the world it describes.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss