Observer — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

the state is a great eater

I see more and more but am wholly unable to look

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Three lines are all Dave Bonta needs to leave a reader unsettled. The poem sets a blunt, almost fable-like claim about power beside a confession about perception, and it never says how the two connect. That gap is where the poem lives.

Take the first line: "the state is a great eater." The word "state" is slippery. It can mean a government, a country, or simply a condition of being. The poem doesn't choose, and both readings work. A state that eats is a devouring machine, swallowing resources, people, attention. A "state" as a condition could also be something that consumes us from inside. The metaphor is odd, too. We usually say a state "governs" or "controls," but "eater" makes it bodily and greedy, closer to an animal than an institution. "Great" adds to the effect. It sounds almost admiring, like calling someone a great talker, so the line has a deadpan, ironic tone. Nothing in it is shouted.

The second stanza turns to the speaker: "I see more and more / but am wholly unable to look." The key to the poem is the difference between *seeing* and *looking*. Seeing happens to us. Images arrive whether we want them or not. Looking is a choice, an act of sustained attention that carries some responsibility. The speaker is therefore flooded with sight and unable to do the one thing that would give it meaning. "More and more" suggests an accumulating pile of images, and the title "Observer" turns sour against it. An observer is supposed to watch carefully, but this one is overwhelmed, or perhaps ashamed, or numb. Judging by the juxtaposition, the poem may be hinting at a world where information and spectacle pour in so constantly that real attention becomes impossible. Another reading is that the speaker simply cannot bear to look at what the state is doing. The text supports either one.

The title also invites a second thought. An "observer" can be a witness, a journalist, or a person who watches on behalf of an authority. The poem doesn't say which, and the ambiguity casts a faint shadow of surveillance over the "state" of the first line. Who is watching whom? That is a reading from the wording rather than a fact the poem states, but the possibility lingers.

Formally, the poem is spare. There is no rhyme and no punctuation, and the only capital letter is the "I," which stands alone among the lowercase words. After the quiet, flat first line, the speaker's self appears small and exposed. The rhythm shifts along with the stanza break. "The state is a great eater" moves in a slightly swaggering, trochaic rhythm, with the stresses falling hard on "state," "great" and "eat." "I see more and more" is made of short, plain words that pile up like the images they describe, and the repeated "more" gives a sense of mounting pressure. The last line then stretches out: "but am wholly unable to look" is the longest of the three, and the polysyllables "wholly" and "unable" slow the reader down just before the line ends on the flat, one-syllable "look." The sentence tries to complete the act and falls short, which is exactly what it describes. There is a quiet pun available in "wholly," which sounds like "holy," though the poem doesn't push it.

The two stanzas also mirror each other. The state eats, taking things in without limit. The speaker, in a way, also consumes, taking in sight after sight, but cannot digest any of it. The comparison is never stated, which is typical of the poem's economy. It lets the reader feel an uncomfortable resemblance between the powerful appetite and the helpless one.

The poem's significance lies in this compression. It makes a large idea, that being flooded with images is not the same as understanding them, small enough to hold in one breath. It doesn't lecture or name a villain. It leaves a paradox on the page and trusts the reader to feel its weight, then asks a harder question than any slogan could: when we see so much and look at so little, what exactly are we observing?

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss