Circumscribed — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

I have seen a ship in a well and a compass in bed

what will become of all my promise in a quiet life

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four short lines, no punctuation, and Dave Bonta's "Circumscribed" still manages to set up a puzzle and then turn it into a worry. The first stanza offers two impossible sights: a ship in a well, a compass in bed. The second drops the surreal and asks, quite plainly, what will become of "all my promise / in a quiet life." The link between the stanzas is the heart of the poem. The ship and the compass are objects made for travel and discovery, and the speaker seems to see his own promise in them, shut away in places where it can't do its work.

Look at where the objects have ended up. A ship needs open water and a horizon, while a well is narrow, vertical and dark, and its water goes nowhere. The picture is faintly comic, like a fairy-tale scale error, but it is also uncomfortable: something built for distance has been fitted into a hole in the ground. The compass is stranger still. Its whole purpose is to say which way to go, and in bed there is nowhere to go. Both settings are domestic, a well being the household's water supply and a bed the most private furniture there is. The poem suggests that the danger to a large ambition is not a storm but a comfortable home. The deadpan "I have seen" sounds like a witness giving evidence, or someone reporting a dream without bothering to explain it, and that flat tone makes the images more unsettling.

The title opens up another layer. "Circumscribed" comes from the Latin for drawing a line around something, and in English it means hemmed in, limited, kept within bounds. The poem's imagery supports this. The mouth of a well is a circle, so the ship sits inside a ring. A compass is also the tool that draws circles, so one way to read "a compass in bed" is as an instrument that could point outward but has been used to mark a boundary. That is an interpretation rather than something the poem states, but the title invites it.

The sound of the poem fits its meaning. There is no rhyme and no regular meter, only short free-verse lines of roughly five to nine syllables. Still, the first line has an easy, almost nursery-rhyme lilt, with its light repeated "a" and "in a" and the beats landing on "seen," "ship" and "well." It sounds like a riddle or a folk saying, which makes the strangeness of the image feel natural. "Well" and "bed" end their lines with the same short vowel, a near-echo that pairs the two images like a muffled couplet. The second stanza has a longer, slower first line, "what will become of all my promise," with soft, rounded sounds in "become" and "promise." Then comes the short, falling "in a quiet life." That last phrase repeats the "in a" pattern of "in a well," and the repetition quietly makes the quiet life a third container, like the well and the bed.

A few words carry a lot of weight. "Promise" works in two ways: it can mean potential, the sense that someone is likely to do great things, or a vow made and not yet kept. Either meaning makes the speaker's position uncomfortable. "All" suggests the amount at stake is large. "Quiet" is the most interesting word because the poem never decides whether it is peaceful or stifling. It echoes the stillness of water in a well and the stillness of someone asleep. The speaker doesn't call this kind of life a failure, and the worry stays real without turning into complaint.

The poem's grammar leaves a similar open space. Nothing is capitalized and nothing is punctuated, so the final question has no question mark. It doesn't rise the way a spoken question does, and it can be read as anxious, resigned or simply unanswered. The poem ends before any reply comes.

What makes "Circumscribed" worth reading is how much it does with so little. It puts the images first and states the feeling only afterward, so the reader has already sensed the problem before the speaker names it. It also describes something many people recognize, the gap between the future they imagined and the ordinary, enclosed life they may end up living. By refusing to say whether that gap is a loss or a comfort, the poem leaves the reader to answer for themselves.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Painted Trillium

Trillium undulatum Painted lady, late riser, you rush out of the ground, get pollinated on the fly
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Initiation

Let him continue in the ground, he who is now dead, where all things hurry—
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss