Voted out — Poem analysis

I am going without speaking

the doors to the park sing old broken notes

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A title like "Voted out" sounds like the end of a meeting: hands raised, a count taken, a result announced. What follows in the poem is the opposite of an announcement. There is no protest and no farewell speech, only a person leaving and a pair of doors that make a sound. The central idea seems to be that rejection, when swallowed rather than argued with, can go quiet in the person and become audible in the world around them. The grief is handed over to an object.

The first line, "I am going without speaking," holds two meanings. The plain one is that the speaker leaves in silence. But "going without" is also the phrase we use for deprivation, as in going without food or sleep, so speech starts to look like something the speaker is being made to do without. That fits the title. A vote is a formal way of having a voice, and someone voted out has just had theirs counted against them. The present tense matters too. "I am going" is not "I went," so the departure is happening now and stretches on without finishing. Rhythmically, the line is a soft, falling eight syllables. "Going" and "speaking" share the same unstressed ending, so the line trails off instead of closing with a bang.

The second stanza turns from the person to the place. "The doors to the park sing old / broken notes" is a personification, probably the creak of hinges heard as music. The sound is worth noticing. "Speaking" and "sing" share their opening s and their closing ng, so the two words echo each other across the stanza break. The speaker refuses speech, and the doors take it up. The human is silent and the thing has a voice.

The line break after "old" is the poem's most deliberate move. Ending the line on that word makes us pause on age before the damage arrives. The notes are old, so perhaps these doors have sounded this way for many other departures, and the speaker's exit is only one more in a long routine. Then "broken" lands, and it works two ways. A broken note is a musical fault, cracked or off-pitch. It is also an emotional word, and although the poem never says the speaker is broken, the doors seem to voice what the speaker withholds. Judging by the imagery, the sadness is never stated and is only heard.

The park adds a further tension. A park is usually the most shared of spaces, belonging to everyone and open to anyone. Giving it doors makes a threshold out of it, a boundary around something meant to be common. The poem doesn't say whether the speaker is walking out of the park or toward it, and that gap keeps the poem from settling into one tidy story. It is enough that someone is on the wrong side of a collective decision, and that the setting is a public one.

In form the poem is free verse, with no rhyme and no end punctuation, split into one line and then two. The lack of a full stop leaves "notes" hanging in the air, like a sound that hasn't quite died away. Sound also does quiet work inside the lines. The long o runs through "going," "doors," "old," "broken" and "notes," a hollow vowel returning like a held note on a low instrument. The last line, "broken notes," is the shortest in the poem, so the poem itself seems to break off.

Its significance lies in this economy. Many poems about rejection explain their hurt, but this one names no emotion at all. The title supplies the social event, the text supplies an exit and a sound, and the reader supplies the feeling. It also quietly inverts what a vote means. Voting is about voices counting, and here a person whose voice has just been counted out answers by not using it. Whether that silence is dignity, defeat or both is left open, and the question lingers in those creaking doors long after the poem's few words are done.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.