Nothing doing — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

I hate haste

at a stand-still I see where to stand

how big must be a committee for doing nothing

one suit with his secretary I did the best I could

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Say "nothing doing" and most people mean a flat refusal: no deal, not a chance. Read the words literally and they describe someone who does nothing at all. Dave Bonta's poem works in the gap between those two meanings. In a handful of short lines it sets a speaker who values stillness against an official world that has turned inaction into an organised activity.

The shape is lean. A single line, "I hate haste," stands alone, followed by three couplets. There is no rhyme, no punctuation, and nothing capitalised except the pronoun "I," so the poem reads like a murmured thought rather than a composed statement. The opening line is blunt, with three heavy beats in a row. It also contains a small trick: "hate" is hiding inside "haste," with only an extra *s* to separate them. The speaker's dislike is built into the word for what he dislikes.

The second couplet turns that dislike into a positive claim: "at a stand-still I see / where to stand." The repetition of "stand" does the work. The first is part of a compound meaning a halt, the second means taking a position. The word shifts from stopping to choosing a stance, and the sentence suggests that you can only decide where you stand once you have stopped moving. The poem doesn't say this outright. The idea sits inside the echo, and "still" drifts into the repeated *s* sounds of "see" and "stand." Haste, by implication, produces motion without position.

Then the tone changes. "how big must be a committee / for doing nothing" has the inverted word order of a grumble: "how big must be," not "how big must a committee be." There is no question mark, so it hovers between a real question and a sarcastic aside. "Committee" is also a physically bulky word, with its doubled *m*, *t* and *e*, and it sits right beside "big." The joke is that the speaker's chosen stillness costs nothing, while institutional nothing requires machinery. One kind of doing nothing is a quiet discipline. The other is a crowd of people arranged around an empty centre.

The last couplet looks like an answer to the question: "one suit with his secretary." The man is reduced to his clothing, a "suit," and defined by hierarchy through "his secretary." The line has no verb, as if the bureaucrat does nothing even grammatically. Then the poem lurches into the past tense with "I did the best I could." Up to this point the speaker has been in the present ("I hate," "I see"). The new tense and the cliché of self-defence make it unclear who is speaking. It might be the suit excusing himself, or it might be the speaker, quietly admitting that his best was not much. The line also falls into a nearly regular rhythm, three iambs in a row (*I DID the BEST I COULD*), which makes it sound like a stock phrase. The poem's smoothest line is its emptiest, and that fits the subject.

What makes the poem worth reading is how well its form matches its argument. It is itself a short piece of "nothing doing," made of few words, no ornament and no resolution. It never explains whether the stillness it praises can survive in a world of committees, or whether "I did the best I could" is an honest shrug or an evasion. It only sets the two kinds of inaction next to each other and lets the reader notice that they are not the same thing.

For a student, the poem shows how much can be done with ordinary language. Hardly any word in it is unusual. The meaning comes from repetition, from an idiom turned back on itself, from a shift in tense, and from the choice to end on a worn phrase that suddenly sounds suspicious.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.