Propagandist — Poem analysis

I bled ink for this war people saw me sing and dance

out of key out of night the fruit of my endeavors

for all for God for the least wrong king

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six short lines are enough for the speaker of Dave Bonta's "Propagandist" to give the game away. The poem is a confession disguised as a boast. The speaker looks back on a career of persuasion, and by the end the persuasion has curdled into doubt. The central idea is that the language of a good cause can be recited with total conviction while the conscience underneath it quietly gives way.

The opening line is the most self-assured: "I bled ink for this war." The metaphor is bold, since it sets the writer's labour beside a soldier's wounds. But the word "ink" undercuts the claim even as it makes it. The speaker bled only ink, and the phrase has the faint smell of self-dramatising. The stresses fall heavily on "bled," "ink" and "war," so the line thuds like a recruitment poster. Then the rhythm lightens. "People saw me sing and dance" is almost jaunty, a nursery-rhyme bounce. The verb is "saw," not "heard," which suggests propaganda as spectacle, a public performance as much as a piece of writing. The sound of the words also links them quietly: "ink," "sing" and, in the last line, "king" echo one another, so the speaker's whole career seems to run from the pen to the throne.

The second couplet is where the poem gets slippery. "Out of key out of night" has no punctuation, so it can attach in two directions. It can finish the previous line, so that the singing and dancing happen out of key and out of night. It can also run forward into "the fruit of my endeavors." "Out of key" is the plainer phrase: the performance is discordant, and the speaker half knows it. "Out of night" is stranger. It could mean something brought out of darkness, or something done by someone out of their senses, or it could hint at work done in secret. The poem doesn't choose, and that openness is part of its effect. "The fruit of my endeavors" then sounds like a stiff, official phrase, the kind used in a medal citation. Fruit should be natural and wholesome, yet here it grows out of a night and a false note. The pleasant word comes with something sour attached.

The last couplet is built as a rhetorical triple: "for all for God for the least." Anaphora, the repeated "for," is the machinery of a slogan, and the three objects move from everyone to the divine to the humble. It sounds like a creed. The line break then does the damage. "Wrong king" arrives alone, two stressed syllables, the shortest line in the poem. Read with the line before it, the phrase becomes "for the least wrong king," which is the language of the lesser evil. All that sweeping rhetoric, for all, for God, for the least, has been spent defending a ruler who is merely less bad than the alternative. The break also allows a harder reading, in which "the least" stands as its own item and "wrong king" is a flat verdict dropped after it. Either way, the grand sentence ends in a shrug or an admission.

The poem's form matches its subject. There is no rhyme, no regular metre and no punctuation, and the speaker's grammar loosens as it goes. The first stanza has a full clause with "I" at its centre. By the end there are only fragments and chanted phrases, as though the speaker has been speaking in slogans for so long that a whole sentence is hard to manage. The poem is itself slogan-sized, short enough to chant, and that is what makes it unsettling. We watch the machinery of persuasion run, and we see where it stalls.

The poem is worth reading because it lets the propagandist speak for himself or herself without caricature. This is no villain with a sneer. The speaker believed, or tried to, and gave something real to the work. The poem leaves open whether the final two words are regret, rationalisation or both. It is also a useful reminder for any reader surrounded by persuasive voices to listen for the moment when the big, noble words stop and the smaller truth comes through. Bonta gives that moment just two syllables.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss