Hawk — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

one hawk above is pure peace

his table is an innocent world with no prisoners in it like a body by moonshine

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Peace, according to Dave Bonta, looks like a single bird hanging in the air. The poem opens with a statement so flat and certain that it almost dares us to disagree: "one hawk above / is pure peace." Hawks are not usually emblems of calm. We think of talons, hunger, the sudden drop. The poem sets out to make the claim feel earned, and in its last three lines it complicates the claim without taking it back.

The opening is built with care. The numeral "one" makes the hawk solitary, and "above" is left hanging without a noun to anchor it. Above what? The ground is only implied, so the bird seems to own the sky. The second line is made of three short words, and the last two, "pure peace," are heavy and sit side by side. The repeated p and the stresses falling together slow the line almost to a stop, much as a hawk riding the air seems to stop. There is no capital letter and no punctuation anywhere in the poem, so the claim arrives without argument, like something simply seen.

The second movement widens the view. "His table is an innocent world / with no prisoners in it." "Table" is the strangest word here, and it works in at least two ways. It may be the hawk's dining table, the place where he feeds. Or it may be the land spread out below, level as a tabletop when seen from height. The poem doesn't choose, and both readings are fair. What matters is how close "innocent" sits to a predator. If the hawk eats at this table, innocence cannot mean harmlessness. It has to mean something closer to the absence of guilt, or of any moral bookkeeping. The hawk does not hate, punish or confine.

"No prisoners" is the phrase doing the most work. It echoes the war idiom "take no prisoners," which means to show no mercy. Placed after "innocent," it splits in two. One meaning is freedom: nothing in this world is caged, held or owed. The other carries a faint smell of slaughter, since nothing here is spared. The poem lets both stand, and the tension between them is where the "pure peace" of the first line begins to look less simple. The sound of the line helps. After the hard k of "hawk," the nasal, murmuring words "innocent," "no," "prisoners" and "in" soften the voice, as if the poem were lowering itself gently over the landscape.

Then comes the only simile, and the least expected: "like a body by moonshine." The hawk suggests daytime, but the poem swerves into night. A body in moonlight is pale, silvered and very still, and it is ambiguous. It might be a sleeper, a lover or a corpse. Peace and death share stillness, and the simile sits right on that border. The choice of "moonshine" over "moonlight" adds another wobble, because the word also means homemade liquor and idle nonsense. I wouldn't claim the poet intends this, but the word suits a poem that seems to ask whether such pure peace is clear sight or a kind of intoxication. The poem also ends without a full stop, leaving the thought open.

The poem's significance lies in how much it asks of a few words. It takes an animal we link with killing and uses it to test what "peace" means. The answer is not sentimental. Peace here seems to be a matter of perspective: from far above, the world looks whole, unfenced and unjudged, like a table laid or a body at rest. It may be a view available only at a distance, or only to a creature without a conscience. The poem leaves us unsure whether to envy the hawk or to be unsettled by it, and that uncertainty is what keeps it alive.

For a student reader, "Hawk" is a useful lesson in compression. One odd noun ("table"), one borrowed idiom ("no prisoners") and one swerving simile ("moonshine") are enough to turn a calm statement into a real question.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss