Landlubbers — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

the dirt was our ship lost beneath the frost

I find myself in cold weather begin to burn all over

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A landlubber is someone clumsy at sea, so a poem with that title seems to promise a joke about people out of their element. Dave Bonta's four lines set up the joke and then quietly take it back. "The dirt was our ship" is funny and tender at once: only people who never leave the land could call the ground beneath them a vessel. But the next line sinks it. The ship is "lost beneath the frost," and what began as play becomes a small elegy.

The poem never says what "our" refers to, and that gap is part of its power. The poem doesn't say who "we" were, or what the dirt stood for. It might be a garden, a field, a childhood place, or a shared life. The text gives only a past tense, a plural pronoun and a cold surface closing over them. Then the second couplet moves to the present and the singular: "I find myself in cold weather." The "we" has become an "I," and the change in pronoun carries the sense of loss without a word of explanation.

The poem's most surprising move is its last line, "begin to burn all over." A speaker left alone in the cold would be expected to shiver. Instead, he burns. That might be grief, desire, fever or anger, and the poem lets all of them stay open. It also fits something true about cold: extreme chill can feel like burning on the skin. The poem sets frost against fire and does not choose between them. The burning may be the old warmth of "our" still alive inside the speaker, or it may be what the cold itself does to a body.

The construction is plain but careful. There are two couplets, with no punctuation and almost no capital letters, so the lines run like thought rather than like statement. The first couplet is tight, with two strong beats in each line ("the DIRT was our SHIP / lost beNEATH the FROST"). The second stretches out, and the longer lines ("I find myself in cold weather / begin to burn all over") feel as if the heat is spreading through them. There is a real rhyme tucked inside the first couplet, because "lost" and "frost" chime in the same line, as if the frost were closing over the ship with a click. The second couplet answers with a looser echo between "weather" and "over," which lets the poem end on an open sound rather than a locked one.

The grammar adds a further twist. Because there is no "and," "I find myself in cold weather begin to burn" can be read two ways. One reading is that the speaker is in cold weather and starts to burn. The other, read straight across the line break, is that he finds himself beginning to burn, almost against his will. "Find myself" suggests surprise, as though the feeling arrived without being invited. The word "begin" matters as well. It suggests the burning has only just started, so the poem ends on a beginning rather than an ending, which sits oddly against the finality of a ship "lost."

The word choices are small but exact. "Dirt" is rougher and humbler than "earth" or "soil," and its short vowel sits comfortably beside "ship." Both are blunt, one-syllable words, which keeps the metaphor from sounding grand. The b-sounds in "beneath," "begin" and "burn" link the poem's two halves, so that the burial in the first couplet and the fire in the second feel like parts of one event. The repeated long o and l of "cold," "all" and "over" lend the ending a rounded, spreading sound.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it holds in so little room. In four lines it moves from play to loss, from past to present, from "we" to "I," and from cold to heat. It does not explain its feeling, and trusts images instead: a ship made of dirt, a frost like water or ice closing over it, a body catching fire in the cold. For a student, it shows that a poem does not need length or ornament. A single mismatched metaphor, a title that teases, and a final line that contradicts the weather can be enough to leave a reader thinking about what exactly was lost, and why the speaker feels so warm.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss