Paper pusher — Poem analysis

Lord I am all morning thin paper

and all afternoon work

which is no book to be

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Three short lines, no punctuation, and a whole working day folded into them. Dave Bonta's "Paper pusher" starts from a stock phrase for an office worker and does something quietly unsettling with it: the person who pushes paper turns into the paper. "Lord I am all morning thin paper" does not say the speaker handles the stuff. He is made of it.

The central idea is that work hollows a person out. The poem splits a day into two halves and gives each a single identity. Morning is "thin paper": fragile, see-through, easy to crease or tear, and perhaps also blank, a page not yet written on. Afternoon is simply "work." The second line drops "I am." The first line has a self and a verb, and the second has neither. By afternoon the speaker has been used up so completely that even the grammar of being has slipped away, leaving only the noun for what he does. The repeated "all" tightens this. It is not part of the morning or afternoon that is spoken for, but every minute of both, with nothing left over.

The last stanza, "which is no book to be," is the hardest line and the most rewarding. The word order bends the sentence so that "to be" lands at the very end, in an old-fashioned, almost prayerful cadence. There is a sad logic in it. Paper is what books are made from, so this paper might have become something bound, finished and worth keeping. Work, the poem says, is not that kind of thing. It is paper that is only ever stacked, shuffled and passed along. A reader may hear a writer's ambition in the word "book," the hope that a life's pages will add up to something, though the poem never says so. "Which" is also slippery. It could point back to "work," or to the whole condition of being thin paper all day. And "no book to be" can be heard as a complaint (what a poor thing to be) or as a flat statement of fact. The poem lets both stand.

The opening word, "Lord," sets up a second ambiguity. It can be a real address to God, a small prayer. It can also be the tired exclamation of someone at the end of a bad day. Placed beside "thin paper" and "book," it may even nudge a reader toward scripture, a book famously printed on thin pages, though that is an association the words invite rather than state. The tone sits between devotion and weary humor, which keeps the poem from becoming merely gloomy.

The form does quiet work. There is no rhyme, and nothing is capitalized except "Lord." Counting syllables gives nine, then six, then six, so the lines shrink as the day wears on. The final line is made entirely of one-syllable words, blunt and flat as a stamped form. "Work" and "book" share a closing *k* sound, a faint echo that pairs them while their vowels pull apart, as if the daily and the lasting were close neighbors who never meet. Each line also sits alone in its own stanza, surrounded by white space. On the page they look like single sheets laid one under another, and the poem itself feels thin.

There is no full stop. The sentence ends on "be," unfinished, like a thought cut off by the next task, or a day that never properly closes. The poem does not tell us what the speaker would like to be instead.

The poem matters for how much it does with so little. It takes a cliché, "paper pusher," and makes it literal, so that a phrase we barely hear turns into an image of a person growing thin. It is funny in the way a sigh can be funny, and the ache underneath is real. In three lines it asks what a day's labor adds up to, and it leaves that question unanswered.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss