Apophasis — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

no creed pleased me like music

though my own road is a wound

I saw mortality touching all things but the night

not knowing is an art— a black one

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Thirty words, four couplets, and a whole attitude toward belief, pain and death. The speaker says that no creed ever pleased them as much as music did, that their own road is a wound, that mortality touches everything except the night, and that not knowing is an art, "a black one." The central idea is a refusal of easy consolation. Faced with suffering and the certainty of dying, the speaker doesn't reach for doctrine. They choose music and the dark, and they treat uncertainty as a discipline to be practised rather than a problem to be solved.

The title explains the method. Apophasis is the rhetorical trick of saying something by denying it, and in theology it is the habit of approaching the divine by listing what it is not. The poem works this way. It opens with "no creed," turns on "not knowing," and carves out an exception with "but the night." It never states what the speaker believes. It marks the places where belief fails to satisfy. Even the one positive thing, music, is the least wordy of the arts, the one that comforts without making a single claim. The title suggests this reading, though the poem never spells it out.

The form matches the argument. There is no rhyme, no regular metre, no capital letters apart from the pronoun "I," and not one full stop. The only punctuation is a dash near the end. The nearest thing to a rhyme is the pairing of "creed" and "pleased," whose long vowels and closing *d* sound almost chime. That echo sits in the first couplet, as if the poem were conceding that doctrine can please a little, just not as much as music. The sentence is a comparison, not a sneer, and that makes the speaker sound honest rather than defiant.

The line lengths do a lot of quiet work. "no creed" is blunt, two syllables that shut like a door, and then "pleased me like music" loosens into soft, flowing sounds. The third couplet has the longest line, "I saw mortality touching all things," which stretches wide enough to take in everything. Then the poem drops to the three syllables of "but the night." Almost every couplet turns on its second line. "A wound," "but the night" and "a black one" each swerve or sharpen what came before, so the reader keeps getting a small jolt at the line break.

The imagery is spare but strange. "My own road" sets a private path against the creed, which is by nature shared and recited together. A road is also something cut across land, so calling it "a wound" makes the speaker's life both a journey and an injury. Then comes the verb in "mortality touching all things." Touch is gentle and almost tender, yet it is the same contact that wounds. Death here is a hand laid on everything. The one thing it skips is "the night." The poem doesn't explain why, so any reading is an inference. Perhaps night is not a thing at all but an absence, and what is only darkness and the unknown cannot die. Perhaps it simply outlasts everything else.

The last couplet pulls the threads together. "Art" quietly links not knowing to music, the poem's earlier source of pleasure. Both are practices that need skill and attention, and neither hands over an answer. Then "a black one" does several jobs at once. It echoes the colour of the night we just met, and it recalls the phrase "black art," with its suggestion of sorcery and forbidden knowledge. Not knowing becomes something slightly dangerous, a craft with its own risks. Because the poem has no closing full stop, it stops without settling, which fits its subject.

What makes it significant is how much it holds in so little space and how little it claims. It doesn't mock belief or announce a new certainty to replace the old one. It admits pain, admits death, and proposes that the most truthful response may be to stay in the dark with music and learn to do it well. A reader who finishes it will find that the poem has offered no creed, and that this was its point.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss