Soterial — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

observing a horse how it minds nothing

is naked and content like a mad god

what will become of people full of sad stories

everybody sick and never a physician

which sea would help us fear what we have done

which curse might trouble us

so small and thin our ear bones are

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A horse stands somewhere, doing nothing in particular, and the poem takes it as a measuring stick. "Soterial" is made of seven unpunctuated couplets that begin by watching an animal and end by listening, uneasily, to the human body. The title is a rare word. It comes from the Greek root for "savior," the same root behind "soteriology," the study of salvation. So before the first line, we know the question is who or what could rescue us.

The opening couplets give the horse an enviable state: it "minds nothing." The phrase works two ways. The horse doesn't object or care, and it also doesn't *mind* in the sense of brooding, keeping accounts, or rehearsing the past. It is "naked and content / like a mad god." The simile is odd and good. A god is complete and answerable to no one, and "mad" suggests a freedom that looks like lunacy by human standards. Nothing in the horse needs forgiving, and that is its divinity. The poem doesn't describe a field, a coat, or a color. The horse is stripped down to its calm.

Then the poem turns on a plain question: "what will become of people / full of sad stories." The horse has no story, but people are *full* of them, like containers. "Everybody sick / and never a physician" is blunt, with its absolutes "everybody" and "never." The physician is the secular cousin of the savior named in the title, a figure who ought to exist and doesn't. The sickness seems moral or spiritual rather than medical, though the poem never says so.

The last three couplets are questions without question marks, each opening with "which." "Which sea would help us fear / what we have done" is the strangest wish in the poem. We expect people to want relief from guilt. Here they want *more* of it, as if the trouble is that they can't feel their own deeds. Judging by the imagery, the sea may stand for something vast enough to humble us, though the poem leaves it open. "Which curse / might trouble us" repeats the idea more darkly: a curse, normally a punishment, would be welcome if it woke us up. Set against the horse's untroubled calm, this makes the "sad stories" look suspect. They may be a way of feeling something about ourselves while avoiding what we have actually done. That is an inference, but the contrast invites it.

The poem's form supports this. Everything is lowercase and unpunctuated, so the lines drift like thoughts rather than pronouncements. They are short, some only two words ("which curse"), and the line breaks leave questions hanging in the air. There is no rhyme, but there are quiet echoes. The "s" sound runs through the poem like a hiss: "sad stories," "sick," "sea," "so small." It begins with the title's first letter and gives the poem a hushed, whispering texture. "Horse" in the first couplet and "curse" in the sixth make a faint slant echo, as though the contented animal and the wished-for punishment are two ends of one thought.

The final couplet changes direction. "So small and thin / our ear bones are" turns the sentence around so the verb arrives last, as if the speaker is pausing to marvel. The ear bones are the tiny bones of the middle ear, hidden deep inside us, and they are the equipment for hearing. After all the unanswered questions, the poem ends on how fragile that equipment is. One reading is that any word of salvation would have to pass through something very slight. Another is that we are simply too delicate, too easily deafened, to hear what we need.

The poem is significant for what it refuses to do. It offers no sermon, no healer, and no answer, and the questions stay open. It sets animal ease against human conscience without claiming either is better, and it lets the reader feel the gap between them. In a handful of short lines, it asks whether the ability to be troubled might be the closest thing to a cure we have.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Painted Trillium

Trillium undulatum Painted lady, late riser, you rush out of the ground, get pollinated on the fly
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Initiation

Let him continue in the ground, he who is now dead, where all things hurry—
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss