Maquiladoras — Poem analysis

bled to make shoes to make clothes

which they did with good will and great pain

who could not say Let us see what we can do to mend all

as a fur of experience rose over us like amber

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The title does what the poem refuses to do: it tells us where we are. A maquiladora is an assembly factory, typically in Mexico, where parts are put together for export, and the word is often stretched to cover the people who work in them. The eight lines never name a country, an owner or a wage. They give us only forty words, four couplets, no punctuation, and a sentence that starts with nobody in it.

"bled to make shoes / to make clothes" opens in lowercase, mid-thought, with no subject. Who bled? The poem lets the missing subject stand for the people the world doesn't bother to name. "Bled" is a blunt verb, suggesting sacrifice, though a reader might also hear dye bleeding through cloth, as if the workers and the product were running into each other. The repeated "to make" mimics the factory floor, the same motion twice, and the second line shrinks by a syllable, as though the effort were being pressed thinner. "Shoes" and "clothes" are the most ordinary objects imaginable, things we put on without a thought. They also close on the same buzzing z, a faint echo that is as near as the poem comes to rhyme.

The second couplet turns on balance: "which they did with good will / and great pain." Two plain adjective-and-noun pairs sit side by side, and the grammar treats them as equals. That evenness is where the unease lives. Willingness and suffering are handed over together, and the sentence doesn't object. The pronoun "they" also keeps these people at arm's length, and the poem seems to know it.

Then comes the strangest grammar of all: "who could not say Let us see / what we can do to mend all." The capital L, with no quotation marks, leaves the spoken sentence floating. The "who" follows "great pain" without a clear antecedent, so it can be read two ways. Perhaps it means the workers, who lacked the power to speak. Or perhaps it means the ones who might have spoken and didn't. The poem doesn't settle this, and the ambiguity seems deliberate. What goes unsaid is also remarkably modest: "Let us see what we can do" is the language of a neighbor offering help, not of a revolution. And "mend" belongs to the very trades the poem began with. Shoes and clothes get mended, so the verb stretches from patching a seam to repairing the world, with "all" as the biggest and plainest word available. These two lines are among the longest in the poem, as though the sentence were reaching for something just out of range.

The last couplet changes the pronoun. For six lines the subjects have been "they"; now, suddenly, it is "us": "as a fur of experience / rose over us like amber." Fur brings back the world of garments, but it is something grown rather than made, warm and unearned. Amber is resin that slowly hardens over a living creature and keeps it, beautiful, golden and fatal for whatever is inside. Judging by the imagery, "experience" here works as insulation: the comfortable accumulation of living, which softens the world and seals us in a little more each year. The verb "rose" is slow, like a tide or a coat of fur lifting. It is also worth noticing that until this point nearly every word is a single syllable. The longer words, "experience" and "amber," arrive only at the end, so the language itself seems to thicken.

The poem's significance lies in how much it carries with so little. It touches global labor, complicity and the failure of imagination without a speech, a statistic or a rhyme. Instead of anger it offers an unfinished sentence, and there is no full stop at the end, so the poem simply stops, like the helpful words nobody said. The reader, who is almost certainly wearing something made somewhere like this, is not accused. Something worse happens: the reader is gently included in the "us" that is slowly being preserved.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Painted Trillium

Trillium undulatum Painted lady, late riser, you rush out of the ground, get pollinated on the fly
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Initiation

Let him continue in the ground, he who is now dead, where all things hurry—
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss