Deracinated — Poem analysis

in our paper office in our cleared wood that only mind will ever own where to write letters home to

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Five lines, no punctuation, no capital letters, and not one finished sentence: Dave Bonta's "Deracinated" reads like a thought cut off just as it is about to arrive. The cutting-off is the point. The poem places a plural "we" in a makeshift place of work, cleared out of woodland, where people try to write home and find that the address has gone missing. Its central idea is that being uprooted is a grammatical condition as well as a physical one. Home is the one thing the poem cannot complete.

The title is built on the word for root, and the images follow it. A wood is "cleared," so trees have been pulled out or cut down, and in their place stands an office made of "paper." The chain of materials is neat and a little bitter. Trees become paper, and paper is what letters are written on. The uprooting that leaves the speakers stranded also supplies the sheets they use to reach back toward what they left. The poem doesn't spell this out. It lets "paper" and "wood" sit in neighbouring lines and trusts the reader to connect them.

"Paper office" is a striking phrase because it makes the workplace sound flimsy and provisional, as if one gust could carry it off. "Cleared wood" is ambiguous in a useful way. It can mean a forest stripped of its trees, or a clearing, an open space made for building. Judging by the imagery, the speakers have settled on ground that was emptied first, and the poem doesn't pretend that's comfortable. The repeated "in our" at the start of the first two lines sounds like a claim being staked, a small chant of possession. The third line then takes the claim apart: this is a place "that only mind will ever own."

That line is the poem's hinge. "Only" and "ever" are absolute words, and they rule out legal title, inheritance and soil under the feet. What remains is "mind," and the missing article ("the mind," "our minds") makes it abstract, almost a place in itself. It can be read as consolation, since a mental territory can't be confiscated and travels wherever its owner goes. It can equally be read as loss, since property that exists only in the head isn't ground at all. The poem doesn't choose. The relative "that" could also refer back to the office or to the wood, and that small uncertainty keeps even the object of ownership from settling.

Syntax carries the theme most of all. The poem is a string of phrases beginning with "in," "in," "that," "where," and no main verb ever turns up. Nobody does anything. Without a stated action the speakers hang inside their setting, much as a plant hangs in the air once its roots are gone. The ending sharpens this. "Where to write" works as a place for writing, but with the line break it also asks a question: where should we write to? The last line, "letters home to," ends on a bare preposition, a direction with nothing at the end of it. We expect a name or a place, and the poem gives us only the word that points.

The sound is plain and unrhymed, built from short, mostly one-syllable words, so the lines move in small deliberate steps. There is one quiet echo: the long *o* of "only," "own" and "home" runs through the poem, linking ownership to the word the poem never reaches. Where a rhyme or a full stop might close the poem, there is only the dangling "to."

This is what makes "Deracinated" worth reading closely. It has a handful of lines and almost no vocabulary beyond the everyday, yet its form enacts its subject, so that the reader feels the missing destination as a gap in the sentence. The reader is left holding the unfinished letter, and in completing it in their own mind, they do what the poem says only mind can do.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss