Truisms — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

lock and own to lack is a sin a dull people are a content people at all the papers

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four short lines, no capital letters, no punctuation, and almost no explanation. "Truisms" gives the reader a handful of sayings and leaves them to work out who is speaking and why. The title promises things so obvious they need no proof. What follows is a set of statements that sound like common sense but turn sinister once you stop to look at them.

Take the opening, "lock and own." It is three syllables of pure command, two verbs with nothing to attach to. The rhythm recalls fixed phrases like "lock, stock and barrel," and perhaps "lock and load," though that is only an echo. The poem never says what is to be locked or owned, so the instruction applies to everything: property, people, ideas. "Own" also carries a second meaning, to admit or confess, as in "own up," which quietly links possession with guilt before the next line has begun.

That line arrives at once: "to lack is a sin." The two l-sounds in "lock" and "lack" bind the lines together, as if the second were the logical consequence of the first. Own things, because not having them is wrong. The line also turns the usual moral order upside down. Traditional lists of sins tend to condemn excess, such as greed or gluttony. Here the fault lies in having too little, so poverty becomes a failure of character. The plain, monosyllabic phrasing, with its steady beat of "to LACK is a SIN," has the confident ring of a proverb, and that is how the poem shows a questionable belief passing itself off as wisdom.

The third line is the longest and the only one built like a complete sentence: "a dull people are a content people." Its symmetry is the most slogan-like thing in the poem. "A dull people" and "a content people" sit on either side of the verb "are," so the two descriptions become interchangeable. The repeated word "people" is worth noticing. It is singular in sense, a mass to be managed, and nobody in it is an individual. The line works as an equation, and the speaker seems pleased with the result: if you want contentment, cultivate dullness. Whether the line is an observation or a policy, the poem leaves open. The word "content" also has a second pronunciation and meaning, as in the content of a document, which prepares for the last line almost by accident.

That line, "at all the papers," is a fragment. Its preposition points somewhere but nothing is said about what happens there. We might imagine someone looking at all the newspapers, or shouting at them. The phrase "at all" also hints at the idiom that usually accompanies a negative, as in "not at all." The papers could be newspapers, which would suggest that these truisms circulate through the press. They could equally be legal documents or deeds, which would tie back to "lock and own." The poem lets both readings stand. Either way, the ending trails off with no full stop, as if the list of sayings could go on indefinitely.

Look at the shape the lines make on the page. They run from three syllables to five, then swell to ten, then shrink back to five. There is no end-rhyme at all. The only musical effects are the lock/lack echo and the doubled "people," and that restraint suits the subject. A rhyming poem would sound too crafted, whereas these lines imitate the flat, repeatable quality of slogans, which persuade through repetition rather than artistry.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it does with so little. It never names a government, an economy or a villain, and it never says that these sayings are false. It simply sets them down in a calm, authoritative voice and trusts the reader to feel the chill. In doing so it shows how easily a harmful idea can be packaged as a "truism," and how a phrase that is short and neat enough can slip past our judgment. The final fragment seems to place the reader among the papers, where phrases like these are taken in without a second thought.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss