Body builder — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

body built of water which hand is first hand

water built of ice and a little quiet

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The title plays the first trick. "Body builder" normally suggests a gym, mirrors and muscle hauled into shape by sheer effort. Then the first line pulls the rug away: this body is "built of water," the most yielding material imaginable. Read as two separate words, the title also splits into a body and a builder, which prepares the question in line two: who or what is doing the building?

That question arrives with no question mark, no capital letter and no punctuation anywhere in the poem. "Which hand is first hand" simply floats, as though the speaker is thinking aloud. The line can be heard in several ways. It might ask whose hand began the work, a maker's hand or the body's own. "First hand" also echoes the everyday phrase for direct, unmediated experience, so the line may ask whether we can ever know our own bodies that way. The repeated word "hand" makes the line loop back on itself, like a question that cannot find a place to start. Nothing in the poem settles which reading is right, and the openness is the point.

The second couplet moves backward through the body's ingredients. "Water built of ice" reverses our usual thinking. We normally say ice is frozen water, but here ice comes first and water is what it becomes, as if liquid were stillness loosened. The chain has a recipe-like logic: body from water, water from ice. Then the last line adds "and a little quiet." Quiet is not a substance at all but an absence of sound, yet it is listed as the final pinch in the mixture. The phrase "a little" is gently understated. The foundation of everything turns out to be nearly nothing, a small measure of silence.

The poem's construction supports this. There is no rhyme in the traditional sense. Repetition does the work instead: "built" appears in both couplets, "water" ends one line and begins another, and "hand" is doubled in a single line. These echoes make the poem feel like a set of nesting containers, each one opening onto a smaller, quieter one. The rhythm helps. Lines one and three have a steady, walking pace (BOD-y BUILT of WA-ter), but in "which hand is first hand" the stresses bunch up at the end, and "first hand" makes the reader pause as if hesitating over the answer. The final line starts with the light, unstressed "and a" and then dwindles through "little quiet," so the poem fades out rather than closing with a click. The long "i" sound in "ice" and "quiet" also links the last two lines, so the ending feels like a sounded-out echo of what came before. The white space between the couplets works as a small silence of its own, a quiet inside the poem about quiet.

The images are cool and spare. Water and ice are physical and almost touchable, which makes the body seem less like a monument and more like a temporary arrangement of something that could melt, flow or still itself. That is a quiet comment on the bodybuilder of the title. Instead of a body made by willpower and discipline, we get one assembled from the least forceful things in nature.

What makes the poem significant is how much it does in roughly twenty words. It starts from the familiar idea that a large part of the human body is water and turns it into a small philosophical puzzle about origins. It also enacts that puzzle. The "hand" of the maker appears in the first half and then vanishes, replaced by ice and finally by silence. The search for a builder ends not with a person or a god but with an absence, and the poem leaves the reader to decide whether that absence is comforting or unsettling. A reader can finish the poem in seconds and still go on turning over that last image, a body that begins in water, goes back to ice, and ends in a little quiet.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss