Instigation — Poem analysis

Dave BontaInspired

time to rise up

we are not rusted

we need no one but one another

we are match-thin like the truth

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four short lines are enough for Dave Bonta's "Instigation" to sound like a call to arms. Its subject is solidarity: a group of people told, or reminding themselves, that they already have what they need to act. The central idea is that strength comes from one another and not from outside help, and that this strength is slight but dangerous, like a match.

The title does a lot of work. To instigate is to stir something up, and the poem behaves like the thing it names. It doesn't describe an uprising or explain a grievance. It simply starts one. "Time to rise up" has no subject and no verb of being; there is no "it is" in front of it. The line arrives like a shout or a slogan, and "rise up" carries several associations at once, including a crowd getting to its feet, dough swelling, and the sun coming over a horizon. The poem doesn't choose among them.

The second line, "we are not rusted," answers a worry the poem never states. Rust is what happens to iron left idle: tools, machines, chains, anything once useful and now stiff from neglect. To say "we are not rusted" is to insist that the speakers can still move and work, and perhaps to push back against an accusation of being worn out. It also quietly sets up the last line. Rust is a slow form of burning, since iron oxidising over years, while a match is the same chemistry made sudden. Bonta never says this, but the poem moves from the slow, dull process to the fast, bright one.

The third line is the longest and the heart of the poem: "we need no one but one another." The repeated "one" is the key sound. "No one" means nobody, and "one another" means each other, so the same word shifts from absence to belonging within a single line. Loneliness turns into companionship through simple repetition. The line also stretches the poem's rhythm. The lines run four, five, nine, then seven syllables, so the poem swells at the moment it talks about people gathering and tightens again as it closes.

The word "we" begins three of the four lines, and "I" never appears. This steady plural voice is the poem's chief method. Nobody stands out as a leader and no opponent is named, so the reader is drawn into the "we" without being told who is being resisted. The poem doesn't rhyme, but sound still holds it together. The short, flat "u" of "up," "rusted," "one," "but," "one," and "another" runs through the lines like a drumbeat. Then "thin" and "truth" end the poem on the soft, breathy "th" sound, which makes the finish feel lighter than what came before.

The last line, "we are match-thin like the truth," is the strangest and best. It is the only simile, and it is surprising because it makes strength out of thinness. A match is slight and easily snapped, yet it can start a fire. The hyphenated "match-thin" fuses the two ideas into one word. Truth is "thin" too, perhaps because it is easy to overlook or easy to break. The poem doesn't promise that truth is mighty. It suggests that truth, like a match, is small until it is struck. The word "match" may also nod to its other meaning of an equal or a partner, which fits the line before it, though that reading is an inference rather than something the poem insists on.

Everything is in lowercase and without punctuation, so the lines look more like a message passed from hand to hand than a formal speech. Nothing stops the voice, and no full stop closes the final line. The poem ends on an image instead of a command, so the reader is left holding the unlit match, and the next move is theirs.

That is much of what makes the poem worth reading. In a handful of plain words it shows how a call to action can be built: a command, a denial of weakness, a promise of mutual support, and a single image that turns fragility into potential. It trusts its reader to supply the rest, and that trust is its own small act of instigation.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss