This is your captain speaking — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

I am the captain leave the going to me

I believe I shall some ordinary afternoon

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Anyone who has flown knows the voice that comes over the speakers: calm, unhurried, slightly bored on purpose. Its job is to make us feel that someone else has everything in hand. Dave Bonta's poem borrows that voice, signalled by the title's quotation marks, and lets it say something no airline would approve. The four lines announce who is in charge, promise to take care of the going, and then quietly admit that the captain intends to go too.

The pivot is in the second line, "leave the going to me." On a first hearing it is pure reassurance: don't worry, passengers, I'll handle the journey. But "leave" is also a verb of departure, and "the going" is an odd phrase that turns travel, or departure, into a thing that can be handed over like a chore. The line works as an instruction ("entrust it to me") and as a half-hidden statement ("let me be the one who leaves"). The captain asks to be left alone with the going, and the passengers, who are really us, are told to stay in their seats.

The third line makes the doubleness harder to ignore. "I believe I shall" stops without a verb, and we silently supply the missing word: *go*, *leave*. The phrasing is strangely hesitant for a captain. Captains in announcements don't "believe"; they know, and they give altitudes and arrival times. "Shall" is formal, old-fashioned, almost ceremonial, like a vow or a will. There is also a sound-link underneath. "Leave" and "believe" rhyme, though they sit in different lines and no one would call the poem rhymed. The echo ties the promise to the intention, so that "leave" pulls "believe" toward it, as if the speaker is talking himself into the act.

The final line, "some ordinary afternoon," is the longest, with seven syllables against the five or six of the others. The poem relaxes into it and slows down, and its three soft, rolling words make the afternoon sound like any other. Nothing in the poem says when or why, and "some" keeps the date vague, as though the captain is describing a plan for a day not yet chosen. The ordinariness is what unsettles us. We expect an exit to arrive with weather, alarms, or drama, and here it is pencilled in for the kind of afternoon on which nothing happens.

The form supports this plainness. There are two couplets, with no punctuation and no capital letters apart from "I." The lack of a full stop matters most. The last line doesn't close the sentence so much as leave it hanging, the way an announcement might trail off when the speaker clicks the microphone off. The white space between the couplets does the work a pause would do on the intercom. The first pair asserts authority, and the second pair undermines it by turning from "I am" to "I believe," from certainty to intention.

What the poem leaves open is its main pleasure. The "going" could be comic, a pilot who has had enough, or literal and ominous, a danger hidden in the cabin's calm. It could be a metaphor for death, or for anyone deciding to walk away from a role that others depend on. The captain who steers other people's lives has a private plan of his own. We might even hear a faint contrast with the way captains are mourned in poetry, as in Whitman's "O Captain! My Captain!", although that is my association, not something the poem claims. Here the captain announces his own leaving, calmly, before anyone can grieve.

It is significant because it makes a reader feel what it is to be a passenger. We are told to trust and to stay put, and the trust is the trap, since the person we trust is the one speaking about departure. In four lines and fewer than twenty words, the poem turns a routine piece of institutional comfort into something unsettling, and it trusts the gaps, the missing verb, the unspecified afternoon, to do the frightening.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.