Inside/outside — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

much company in a little room an old man sat boasting how he had been in prison

and there was a field with four horses and the light of evening

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six short lines, no punctuation, no rhyme, and still a whole argument about what it means to be free. Dave Bonta's "Inside/outside" is built from two pictures set side by side: a packed room where an old man talks, and an empty field where nothing speaks at all. The poem never explains how they relate. It leaves the reader to feel the pull between them.

The first stanza is crowded in both sense and sound. "Much company in a little room" has a proverbial ring, as though it were an old saying, and it packs people in. The words are almost physically squeezed together, with the m of "much," "company" and "room" repeating like shoulders pressing. Then comes the old man, who "sat boasting / how he had been in prison." The irony is quiet but sharp. He is sitting in a confined space, surrounded by listeners, and what he is proud of is having once been confined. Prison has become a possession, a story that earns him an audience. The verb "boasting" does the judging, since the poem could have chosen "telling" or "remembering." Past confinement has turned into currency in the present room.

Then the poem changes. "And there was a field / with four horses / and the light of evening." The lines get shorter, and counting syllables roughly, the first stanza runs about nine, six and seven, while the second thins to five, four and six. The poem seems to exhale. No people appear in this stanza, and nobody speaks. The horses are specific and countable, and "four" gives the scene the plain precision of something actually seen. Even the sound loosens the grip of the room: "four" and "horses" share a soft, open vowel, a gentle chime where the first stanza had clustered consonants.

The final image is "the light of evening," and it is the one thing in the poem that cannot be boasted about or owned. The old man has a story, but light belongs to no one. Evening also quietly echoes the old man's age, the day nearing its end as he is near the end of his life, though that is an inference from the imagery rather than anything the poem states. What the light does clearly is end the poem on something that opens outward, while the first stanza ends on the word "prison."

The title is worth slowing down for. The slash between "Inside" and "outside" can read as a divider, a wall, or as a hinge joining two halves of one thing. The poem plays with both readings. The old man was once inside a prison and is now inside a room, so "inside" follows him around. The field, by contrast, seems to be the "outside," yet the poem never says anyone is in it. It simply exists. Even the grammar helps: "there was a field" is the language of storytelling, an existence announced rather than a scene entered. And since everything is in the past tense ("sat," "was"), the speaker too is recounting something remembered, which quietly puts the poem in the same business as the old man, telling a story to a room. Whether that makes the speaker's account a rival to his boast or a gentler version of it is left open.

That openness is where the poem's significance lies. It says nothing about freedom directly, yet it makes the reader weigh two kinds of it: the social, talkative kind, where experience is turned into anecdote, and the wordless kind, where horses stand in a field and the light changes. There is no moral and no verdict on the old man, who may be moving or merely vain. Placing the images next to each other, much as a haiku does, is enough to make the reader notice what the room is missing. Because no date or context comes with the poem, it is best read exactly as it stands, and as it stands it is very short and rewards a second reading, since the field looks different once you have sat in the crowded room first.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss