If it bleeds — Poem analysis

the news makes madness to order

nobody was to be offended

we live now perpetually fighting battles

how strange that you should be dead

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Journalists have a saying that the title cuts in half: if it bleeds, it leads. Dave Bonta prints only the first clause and leaves the second to the reader, which is a smart move. The four lines that follow work out what happens when the bleeding stops being a headline and becomes personal. The word "bleeds" hangs over the poem until the last line, when blood finally arrives in a form no news bulletin could package.

The opening line, "the news makes madness to order", twists the familiar phrase "made to order". Madness becomes a product, stitched up on demand for customers, like a suit or a restaurant meal. Notice too that the news is the grammatical subject and does the making. It is not a window onto the world's craziness but a factory for it. The repeated m-sounds in "news makes madness" give the line a low, mechanical hum, as if the machinery were running in the background.

The second line, "nobody was to be offended", shifts into the passive voice and the past tense, and it sounds like a clause from a memo. Who decided that nobody was to be offended? The poem never says, and that missing agent seems to be the point, since this is how institutions speak when they want to sound neutral. Set beside the first line, it produces a quiet irony: a culture that sells outrage while insisting on inoffensiveness. A gentler reading is also possible, in which a good intention has simply gone sour. Either way, the line feels smoothed over, with every sharp edge sanded off.

Then comes the longest line, "we live now perpetually fighting battles". It has eleven syllables against the first line's eight, and the clumsy, four-beat "perpetually" in the middle makes it trudge, which suits its subject. The pronoun "we" pulls the reader in, and "now" hints at a change from some earlier state. The battles have no named enemy and no goal. Fighting is simply the condition of life, a war metaphor that has lost its war.

The last line, "how strange that you should be dead", is where the poem turns. It is the first time anyone is addressed directly. "The news", "nobody" and "we" were all general, and now there is a "you". The line also drops to seven syllables, every one a single-syllable word, so after the long Latinate "perpetually" the language becomes bare and almost childlike. "Strange" is a startling choice. It is not "terrible" or "unbearable", just a mind failing to take in what it knows, and the slightly formal "should be" gives the sentence a stunned politeness. The poem never says who the dead person is, and that restraint keeps the line open to any reader's own loss. Judging by the war imagery before it, the death might be a casualty of those battles, but the text does not say so.

Formally, the poem is four unrhymed, unpunctuated, lowercase lines, each a complete sentence set apart from the others. Without full stops or capitals, the lines read like items on a ticker or a scrolling feed, each one a scrap with no explanation attached. The poet leaves out the connecting words ("because", "so", "meanwhile") and lets the reader supply them. That gap is where the poem's thinking happens: the first three lines are public, abstract and loud, while the fourth is private, concrete and quiet.

The poem matters because it avoids making a speech about media culture and instead stages a contrast. The first three lines describe manufactured, endlessly renewed alarm. The fourth shows something that cannot be manufactured and does not "lead" anywhere, a death that is no story, only a fact the speaker has trouble believing. By ending on the word "dead" after so much noise, the poem suggests that real loss does not fit the news cycle, and that a few plain words can do what a thousand headlines cannot.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss