Limp — Poem analysis

flag too great to stir like a new carcass not used to any airs foul or sweet

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four lines, no punctuation, no capital letters, and not one finished verb: Dave Bonta's "Limp" hangs on the page much like the flag it describes. Look at the first line, "flag too great to stir." Nothing in it says what the flag is doing. There is no "hangs" or "droops," and the only verb is "stir," tucked into an infinitive, a verb that hasn't started yet. The grammar goes slack along with the cloth. The title supplies the missing word, so the poem never has to say "limp" about the flag. The word is already draped over it.

On the surface this is a windless day and a flag with nothing to lift it. The real interest lies in the word "great." "Too great to stir" can mean physically too big and heavy, a mass of cloth that needs more than a breath to move it. It can also mean too grand, too important, too dignified to bother. Both senses fit in one word, and the second turns the line into gentle mockery. Flags usually stand for pride and ceremony, and here that pride has become dead weight. The poem never says whose flag it is, so I read the satire as an inference from "great" rather than a stated target. The poem seems more interested in grandeur that has gone still than in any particular nation.

The simile is the poem's boldest move: the flag hangs "like a new carcass." Flags are normally compared to living things, as when they ripple, snap or wave. Here the comparison is to a dead animal. The word "new" matters, because this carcass is fresh, heavy and slack, not yet a skeleton or a rotting thing. Sound ties the two images together before the simile even arrives. "Flag" and "carcass" share the same short *a* and a hard, stopped consonant, so the ear links them before the mind does.

The last two lines turn on the word "airs." Most obviously, airs are breezes, the very thing the flag lacks. But "putting on airs" means showing off, which is exactly what a flag in full flutter seems to do. This flag has no airs in both senses, and the pun deflates it twice. Airs can also be tunes, which adds a faint suggestion of fanfare that never plays. Then "foul or sweet" moves the poem from sight to smell. We are asked to imagine the air's odours, and the phrase suggests a verdict: whether the wind brings praise or insult, flattery or rot, the flag cannot respond. The phrase "not used to" also gives the carcass an odd innocence. It is newly dead and unfamiliar with its condition, which brings a flicker of pity into a grim image.

The form follows the same slackening. The syllable counts run roughly five, five, six, three, so the poem ends abruptly, like cloth dropping back against a pole. It doesn't rhyme and has no regular metre, though the first line has a slow, tolling rhythm, with stresses falling on FLAG, GREAT and STIR. Short lines and the missing punctuation leave the poem without a full stop, so it simply runs out of breath. The final word, "sweet," is soft and unexpected after "carcass" and "foul," and it leaves a faintly ironic aftertaste.

The poem is significant for how much it does with so little. It builds one image and lets a pun and a simile do the work of an argument. It is also a poem about absence. The wind never appears, and everything is defined by what is missing: the verb that isn't there, the airs the flag isn't used to, the movement that doesn't come. For a student reader it shows how a very short poem can carry layers, with an ordinary scene on top and a quiet joke about pride and display underneath. It also shows that meaning can sit in a single ambiguous word like "great."

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss