Sun tea — Poem analysis

night coolness I surrender to the season

disguised as ivy go wild with hand in dirt

whisper against the land like a kingdom of snow

why should I treasure the same words as others

I shall make tea out of the sun and have all the questions

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Nothing in "Sun tea" is boiled, forced or hurried, and that is the poem's whole argument. Sun tea is made by setting a jar of water and tea leaves in the light and waiting, so the heat works while you do nothing. Dave Bonta's ten lines take that lazy, domestic method and turn it into a small declaration of independence for anyone tired of speaking in other people's phrases.

The poem opens in surrender. "night coolness" is a fragment with no verb, just a sensation, and the next line gives in to it: "I surrender to the season." The surrender is oddly active, though. What follows, "disguised as ivy go wild / with hand in dirt," is grammatically slippery. Is the speaker disguised as ivy, or is the season? Is "go wild" a description or an instruction? With no punctuation and no capital letters, the phrases slide into one another and the reader has to choose. The looseness seems deliberate, since giving yourself to a season means blurring the line between self and plant. Ivy is a shrewd choice, because it creeps, clings and covers. "Hand in dirt" adds touch and soil, so the surrender is physical rather than abstract.

Then the temperature drops: "whisper against the land / like a kingdom of snow." The image jumps from green to white, and the sound follows it. Soft s-sounds run through "surrender," "season," "whisper" and "snow," so the poem seems to hush itself. A "kingdom" of snow is a whole realm that mutes everything beneath it, much as ivy swallows a wall. The first half is cool, nocturnal and quiet, which makes the title's sun feel far away.

The poem turns on its only question: "why should I treasure the same / words as others." It has no question mark, so it sounds muttered rather than demanded. The line break helps. It ends on "the same," so for a moment sameness itself seems to be the thing treasured, and only the next line reveals the object: "words as others." The enjambment acts out the complaint, since the sentence spills over into repetition before the speaker can object to it.

The final couplet changes the grammar. "I shall make tea out of the sun / and have all the questions" is the poem's first confident future, set against the opening present-tense surrender. The claim is impossible and also ordinary. You cannot make tea from the sun, yet sun tea does exactly that. The title becomes an act, and the poem has moved from night to daylight, from cold to warmth. The surrender at the start now looks less like defeat than like steeping. The last phrase is the sharpest. Instead of answers, the speaker wants "all the questions," and "all" sounds almost greedy. Questions replace the shared words from the previous stanza as the thing worth treasuring. Judging by this pairing, the poem suggests that originality comes less from inventing new vocabulary than from patient, bodily openness to the world.

The form supports this. There are five unrhymed couplets, and the lines are short, ranging from four syllables ("with hand in dirt") to eight ("I shall make tea out of the sun"), with no regular meter. The couplets promise balance, but the breaks often cut through the middle of a phrase ("the same / words"), so the stanza shape and the syntax pull against each other. The lowercase lines and the lack of end punctuation mean the poem never formally closes. That suits a text that ends on questions rather than conclusions.

The poem is significant for how much it carries in so little space. It makes a case for a whole way of writing, which is receptive, unhurried and wary of borrowed language. It does so through a humble kitchen image rather than a lecture. It also reverses the usual idea of effort. Here the speaker lets the season, the dirt and the sun do the work, and the poem comes out of that stillness.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss