Crisis of identity — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

in the morning I was a wide shoe at noon a committee and after dinner a bus which toward night began to ache

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four short lines, no punctuation, and an entire day has been used up. Dave Bonta's "Crisis of identity" borrows the heavy vocabulary of psychology and then does something odd and deadpan with it. Instead of a tormented person asking "who am I?", we get a speaker who simply keeps turning into something else: a wide shoe in the morning, a committee at noon, a bus after dinner. The crisis is not a dramatic collapse. It is what an ordinary day does to a person.

The three transformations are carefully chosen. A shoe is humble, private and close to the ground, made for one foot. The adjective "wide" is a curious touch. Judging by the image, it suggests roominess and ease, a self with space left in it, though a wide shoe could also be one that fits nothing in particular. Then comes "a committee," and the poem makes a sudden leap from object to crowd. The speaker is no longer one thing but a roomful of voices, a self that has to deliberate and compromise. The word itself is long and shuffling, a faintly comic piece of office language set against the plain monosyllables around it. Finally there is "a bus," both a machine and a public space, something that follows a fixed route and lets strangers on and off.

These images are not random, and the poem's central idea seems to lie in what they have in common. Each one carries or processes other people. The shoe bears a single foot, the committee takes in many opinions, and the bus holds a whole crowd of passengers. The load grows as the day goes on, and so the last line feels earned: the bus "began to ache." Ache is a word for bodies, not vehicles. Either the bus has acquired a body, or the speaker's own tired body has come back through the metaphor. The grammar allows both, since "which" attaches to the bus while the "I" has been the subject all along. The poem suggests that identity can be worn away by the roles we play for others, until the only thing left to tell us who we are is fatigue.

The construction is minimal but precise. The verb "was" appears only once, in the first line, and the next two lines simply drop it ("at noon a committee," "after dinner a bus"). That gap makes the changes feel quick and unceremonious, like costumes swapped between meetings. The time markers also shift in an interesting way. "Morning" and "noon" are fixed points, "after dinner" is tied to an event, and "toward night" is only a direction. The day stops being measured and starts to drift, which fits a speaker who is losing hold of the hours as well as of the self.

There is no rhyme, but the poem has a quiet sound pattern. The long "oo" of "shoe" is echoed almost at once by "noon," so the first two lines link together before the poem moves on. "Bus" is a short, blunt syllable that lands like a thud, the sound of something heavy. The last line is slower, with its long vowels in "night," "began" and "ache," and the line lingers where the others hurry. The lines run to roughly eight, six, seven and seven syllables, so the committee line is the briskest, as if the meeting had been adjourned almost before it began. The lack of punctuation matters too. The poem never gets a full stop, so the ache is left open, still going on when the words end.

What makes the poem worth reading is the gap between its title and its tone. "Crisis of identity" promises something grand and anguished, but the lines answer in the flat voice of someone reporting their schedule. That mismatch is funny, and then the last line makes the joke hurt a little. In barely two dozen words, the poem turns a familiar phrase into a fresh picture. The self here is not a deep, hidden core but a series of jobs, defined by what it carries for other people, until the weight finally registers in the body.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss