Depressive — Poem analysis

lodged in our bed on a black afternoon

you see bedlam with cold eyes

since light can spoil try gin or sake

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six lines, no punctuation, no capitals except in the title: Dave Bonta's "Depressive" looks on the page like something left lying around, which suits its subject. A person is in a shared bed in the middle of the day, and the person watching them has run out of useful things to say. The central idea is that depression rewrites what a person sees, turning a quiet room into chaos. The poem also admits how thin the help of those nearby can be, since all the speaker has to offer is a drink.

The title is a noun, a label that names someone by their condition. The poem then does the opposite and puts a person in a bed. "Lodged in our bed" is a striking start. To be lodged is to be stuck, like a splinter or a bullet, but a lodger is also someone who has moved in and might stay. Grammatically the word attaches to "you", so the person seems fixed in place, almost an object. The pronoun "our" matters too. The speaker shares this bed and is part of the scene, not a clinician looking in from outside. Then comes "a black afternoon". Afternoon should be the brightest, busiest stretch of the day, and here the mood has been painted over the clock.

The second couplet gives the poem's most interesting word. "Bedlam" comes from the nickname of London's Bethlem hospital for the mentally ill, and it came to mean uproar and chaos. It also has "bed" inside it, so it echoes the "bed" two lines earlier. The sound links stillness to riot, and that is the point: the body lies motionless while the mind sees a madhouse. The eyes are "cold". They are not wet with tears or wild with panic. They are detached, taking in disorder without feeling anything about it. The speaker can only report this by watching the eyes, which makes the distance between the two people painfully clear.

The final couplet turns on "since", a small logical word applied to an illogical situation. "Light can spoil" works in more than one way. Light can behave like milk, something that goes off. It can also be the thing that ruins, the way a flash of daylight fogs unprocessed film. Either way, the usual order is reversed, and light is the danger and not the cure. What follows is "try gin or sake", a suggestion as casual as a menu offered at a party. Both drinks are clear, almost the colour of light, so the remedy is a bottled, dimmed substitute for the thing that supposedly spoils. Any reader will also notice that alcohol is no friend to a low mood. And "sake" invites a pun on "for whose sake?", a question the poem leaves hanging. The tone could be gallows humour or tender desperation, and the poem never says which. That uncertainty feels honest.

The construction is tight. Three couplets make three moves: where we are, what is seen, what is advised. The lines are short, mostly four syllables, and the longest, "on a black afternoon", stretches slightly, as a bad afternoon does. There is no end rhyme, but there are quiet sound-echoes. The long *i* of "light", "eyes" and "try" runs through the second half, and the soft *s* of "since" and "sake" frames the last couplet. Without punctuation, the line breaks do all the work. "Black afternoon / you see bedlam" flows together before the reader decides where one thought ends. The poem also has no full stop, so it ends on an instruction and not a resolution. The compression and the final turn recall haiku, and the Japanese word "sake" nudges the reader in that direction, though that is an impression and not a claim about the poet's intentions.

What makes the poem worth reading is its restraint. It does not describe despair at length, and it offers no cure or reassurance. It shows one afternoon from the other side of the bed, where love and helplessness sit together and the best available advice is slightly absurd. In so few words it captures the way depression can make the people around it feel useless, and it does so with a dry, unhappy wit.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss