Culinary — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

I roll the whole morning into a soup

backwater to whitewater

what I have is almost as much as I desire

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A morning is usually something that happens to us. In Dave Bonta's "Culinary," it becomes something we cook. In six short lines the speaker gathers up the hours, with no ingredient left out, and rolls them into a soup. What begins as a kitchen image ends as a quiet statement about appetite: what the speaker has is "almost as much / as I desire." The central idea is that a life can be nourished by what it already holds, and that the gap between having and wanting, though never quite closed, can shrink to a size that is comfortable to live in.

The poem is built from three unrhymed couplets in free verse, and each couplet does a different job. The first performs an action, the second paints a scene, and the third reflects. The lines are short and the diction is plain, so the poem moves at the pace of someone talking quietly to themselves while stirring a pot.

The first couplet rests on one verb. "Roll" can suggest rolling dough, or gathering something loose into a single mass. It can also suggest a rolling boil, the heat that makes a soup. The sounds support this. "Roll," "whole" and "soup" share long, rounded vowels, so the line feels as full and curved as the pot it describes. The line break after "morning" matters too. For a moment the morning hangs there as itself, a whole stretch of time, and then the next line dissolves it into broth. Ordinary time is being turned into something edible and shareable.

The second couplet drops the "I" and the verb entirely: "backwater / to whitewater." It reads like a fragment of thought, and it carries the most surprising imagery. The scene leaps from kitchen to river, and the reader has to make the connection. One reading is that the morning itself had slow, stagnant stretches and fast, churning ones, and the soup holds both. Another is that the pot passes from stillness to a foaming boil. Both readings work because water is the main ingredient of any soup, so the metaphor never really leaves the pot. The pairing "backwater" and "whitewater" shares its second half, and only the first syllables, "back" and "white," change. The sound turns on a hinge as the water turns from sluggish to turbulent. The word "to" implies travel, so even this two-word image has a direction.

The final couplet steps out of imagery into statement, and its language is strikingly bare: "what I have is almost as much / as I desire." Apart from "almost" and "desire," nearly every word is a single syllable, which makes those two words stand out. The enjambment helps. After "as much," the sentence seems to promise sufficiency, and "as I desire" then tilts it into longing. The most important word is "almost." The speaker does not claim to have enough, only nearly enough. That small hedge keeps desire alive, since an appetite that was fully satisfied would no longer be an appetite. It also makes the claim feel honest. The poem does not preach contentment. It reports it with a slight, human shortfall.

The title adds another layer. "Culinary" is a formal, almost catalogue-like word for such a homely poem. Judging by the way it hovers over the lines, it may suggest that the speaker sees this act as a craft, a way of making something from whatever the day provides. The poem is itself a kind of soup, with a few ingredients, no waste and everything cooked down.

Its significance lies in this restraint. Many poems about desire dwell on what is missing. This one gives lack only a single word, "almost," and spends the rest of its lines on the abundance of a morning. By turning time into food, it suggests that the way to be satisfied is to take in the whole day, the backwater and the whitewater, and to be grateful for it. It also leaves a faint ambiguity. We cannot be sure whether the soup is rich or thin, or whether the speaker is serenely content or gently making do. That uncertainty gives the poem its flavor.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss