Janus poem — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

Mirror, mirror

Hello, silk: a girdled witch hazel switch, curdled-milk yellow. The stark noose of bare wood bears no tooth mark. Light snow fogs the view, logs glow white as egrets, Victoria’s secrets, as hope against hope.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A single twig of witch hazel carries a whole winter in Dave Bonta's "Janus poem," five lines that look in two directions at once. The title borrows the name of the Roman god of doorways, who was shown with two faces, one turned forward and one back. The line "Mirror, mirror" beneath it promises reflection and doubling. What the poem doubles is a feeling. A yellow switch glimmering in the snow is a delight and a threat at the same moment, and the poem's central idea is that hope lives right beside that unease. It does not cancel it out.

The opening greets the twig like a person: "Hello, silk." The warmth is immediately complicated by sound. "Girdled" and "curdled" are near-rhymes, and "witch hazel switch" chimes on its own ending, so the line feels like a set of paired reflections. Yet the pairs pull apart in meaning. "Silk" and "girdled" belong to the vocabulary of clothing, even underclothing, so the plant seems dressed in something intimate. "Curdled-milk yellow" then sours the sweetness. The colour is gentle and slightly sickly at once.

The second line darkens. "The stark noose of bare wood bears no tooth mark" piles up heavy monosyllables, with "stark," "bare," "wood," "bears" and "mark" all landing hard. After the loose, musical first line, the rhythm clenches. "Stark" and "mark" rhyme like a door shutting. The image works by absence. The ring of bare wood looks like a noose, and the poem tells us what did not make it: no tooth. Judging by the imagery, "girdled" here means a ring of stripped bark, yet the poem never says who or what did it. That gap leaves a faint, unexplained menace.

Then the snow arrives and the sound softens: "Light snow fogs the view, logs glow white." The rhymes "fogs/logs" and the echo of "snow/glow" are cozy, almost lulling, and the sentence blurs its own outlines as the snow blurs the landscape. Whiteness now becomes the poem's engine, driving a chain of comparisons: "as egrets, Victoria's secrets, as / hope against hope." The jump from a bird to a lingerie brand to an abstraction is startling and funny, and the rhyme of "egrets" with "secrets" holds the leap together. The joke is not random, either. It reaches back to "silk" and "girdled" and shows that the poem's first line was already quietly playing with undergarments. Delicate things that are white, fragile and half-hidden are all lined up, and hope is placed at the end of the row as the most fragile of them.

That line also shows how the Janus idea works in the structure. The middle line begins and ends with "as," so it works as a hinge. Read from the top, logs glow white *as* egrets, *as* hope. Read from the bottom, the poem begins with "hope against hope" and finishes at "Hello, silk... curdled-milk yellow." The lines hold up almost as well in this reversed order, but the mood changes. Downward, the poem ends on a hope that is already doubting itself. Upward, it ends on a greeting that has gone slightly sour. The phrase "hope against hope" is a small mirror in itself, a word facing its own repetition across the word "against."

The poem's significance lies in this economy. In about thirty words of line, it keeps colour, sound and syntax working toward one effect. Form here is not decoration. A poem built to be read two ways enacts the idea that the same winter scene can be a gift or a warning, and the reader has to hold both. Even the short last line, with only three stresses, seems to hold its breath. The poem doesn't resolve its doubt. It lets the twig glow in the snow, and it leaves us looking both ways.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss