Erasure — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

this mind of a child may I be ever thankful for it

at noon and at midnight making things to my content out of found carcasses

which quite overthrow how I believe I have to see

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dave Bonta's «Erasure» is one unpunctuated sentence that begins in thanks and ends in something close to rebellion. The speaker is grateful for "this mind of a child". It is not a memory of childhood but a mind still in use, working "at noon and at midnight," making "things to my content / out of found carcasses." Whatever it makes "quite overthrow / how I believe I have to see." The central idea is that a childlike way of making, scrappy and unembarrassed and happy with whatever is lying around, can undo the adult's settled rules about what deserves attention and how to look at it.

The grammar carries much of the meaning. The opening couplet is a wish, not a statement: "may I be ever thankful for it." That subjunctive sounds like a small prayer, and it admits that gratitude is not automatic. A gift this useful could be taken for granted or lost. Then the sentence slides sideways. "Making" hangs off "mind," so the mind itself becomes the maker and the speaker stands half aside, watching. The last stanza opens with "which quite overthrow," and the plural verb matters. "Which" cannot point back to the singular mind, so it must refer to the things made or to the carcasses themselves. The poem never settles which. Either the creations overturn the speaker's way of seeing, or the dead things do, and the poem gains from both readings.

The imagery is blunt. "Carcasses" is a rough word, bodies stripped of life and left lying about. A child can treat such things as raw material without squeamishness, and the word suggests the speaker has kept that lack of squeamishness. "Found" adds the idea of scavenging, of making from what turns up instead of what is ordered or approved. The title may nod to erasure poetry, in which a new text is carved out of an existing one by removing words, and "found carcasses" would fit that picture of leftover, dead language. That is an inference, since the poem never says so. Even without it, the title works on the final lines. Erasure means rubbing something out, and here what gets rubbed out is the speaker's sense of how seeing is supposed to go. "Overthrow" is a word for coups and fallen governments, so the speaker's inner order is treated like a regime. Next to it, "how I believe I have to see" is carefully worded. "Have to" suggests duty, and "believe" quietly admits that the duty is only a belief, not a fact.

The sound is plain and unshowy. There is no rhyme, no capital letters and no full stop, and the vocabulary is almost all short everyday words. The stanzas run two, three and two lines. The three-line middle, where the making happens, forms the poem's core, with gratitude on one side and consequence on the other. The two longest lines, "may I be ever thankful for it" and "how I believe I have to see," are the ones where the speaker examines himself. The lines about the work itself are quicker and lighter. Hard k sounds gather in "child," "content," "carcasses" and "quite," giving the middle of the poem a slightly clattering, hands-on texture. "Noon" and "midnight" stretch the activity across a whole day, light and dark, so this making never stops. And "to my content" sounds like the familiar "to my heart's content" with the heart removed. The phrase feels leaner, and it also lets "content" hint at what a thing contains, the material of the making.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it fits into seven lines without becoming cozy. A child's mind here is not sweet innocence. It scavenges the dead, it makes without asking permission, and it unsettles the grown-up who has to live alongside it. The poem also behaves as it describes, building its effect from ordinary words with nothing wasted. The missing full stop leaves "overthrow" hanging, as if the overturning were still going on. For a student, the lesson is in the small words. "Quite," "have to" and "believe" carry the whole argument.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.