Dilettante — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

as a kite I could be impertinent to the weight of numbers

the weight of cellars where night is spoiling

I fear the atelier if we must have hands

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A kite is a shrewd opening image for a poem called "Dilettante". The word comes from the Italian for "to delight": a dilettante loves an art for the pleasure of it rather than as a trade. In Dave Bonta's six lines, that pleasure becomes a small drama between lightness and weight. The speaker begins by imagining the carefree rise of a kite and ends by confessing a fear of the workshop and of the hands it demands.

The first couplet is built on a pun. "As a kite I could be impertinent / to the weight of numbers." Impertinent usually means cheeky, and a kite is cheeky toward gravity, bobbing above the heavy ground. But the word also carries its older sense of "not pertaining", of being irrelevant. A kite does not belong to arithmetic. "The weight of numbers" suggests totals, measurements and sheer quantity pressing down on a person, and anyone who has felt reduced to marks and scores will recognise it. Notice the verb, though: "could be". The freedom is only a possibility, and it is granted only "as a kite", never as the speaker's own self.

The second couplet drops the poem from sky to basement. "The weight of cellars / where night is spoiling" repeats "weight", but the lightness is gone. Cellars are places for storing things, and the poem treats night as a stored good that has been kept too long and is going off. There is also a faint echo of the idiom "spoiling for" a fight, so the darkness may be restless as well as rotten. Without punctuation, the line break leaves "night is spoiling" hanging, and the phrase feels sour and a little eerie. The poem never says what the cellar stands for. Judging by the contrast with the kite, it may be everything the speaker could escape by staying weightless: stored-up obligations, unfinished work, whatever lies under a life.

The last couplet turns from image to confession. "I fear the atelier / if we must have hands." Atelier is the French word for an artist's workshop, and set beside the Italian title it makes the studio sound like a grand, slightly foreign place where serious work is done. The dilettante dabbles outside; the atelier is where one commits. Then comes the sudden "we". After two couplets of "I" and impersonal images, the speaker widens the fear to include everyone, and the final condition is blunt: if making requires hands, then it requires effort, skill and the risk of a clumsy result. There is an irony here too. A kite looks free, but it only flies because someone's hand holds the string. The freedom of the first couplet already depended on the thing the speaker says they fear.

The poem's shape supports this movement. It has three unrhymed couplets, all lowercase, with no punctuation at all, so nothing is closed off or decided. The first line is the longest, about ten syllables, and it stretches out on the four-syllable "impertinent" like a kite string paying out. After that the lines shrink to five or six syllables, and the final line is nothing but short, hard words: "if we must have hands". It lands like something set down heavily. The sounds help as well. "Kite", "I" and "night" share a long vowel, quietly tying the airy image to the dark one. "Weight" and the last syllable of "atelier" share another, so the thing the kite escaped seems to be waiting in the studio.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it neither flatters nor scolds the dilettante. It lets lightness be genuinely attractive, and it lets the fear of commitment sound honest rather than shameful. The poem is itself light, six lines and one bright image, yet it is about the dread of what has weight. It ends on a condition, "if we must", rather than a decision, which leaves the reader exactly where the speaker stands: still holding the string.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss