The Hanged Man — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

who takes an hour to make despair an enemy

and their doubtful body trust in another

if he should suddenly die there is nothing but what is undercover now

is life therefore a letter from myself which to answer I will be accountable for

among other things I wish on the cards

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Read the title as the first words of the poem and the opening finds its grammar: *The Hanged Man, who takes an hour to make despair an enemy.* Without that join, the lowercase "who" floats unattached, much like the figure on the tarot card the title names. It is a small trick, but it sets the poem's method. Nothing is fully anchored, and the reader has to supply the missing connections.

The Hanged Man is traditionally read less as a sign of death than of suspension: a figure dangling, upside down, giving something up in order to see differently. The poem seems to work with that idea. Its first image is about time and effort. It takes "an hour" to turn despair into "an enemy," and the verb "make" matters here. An enemy is something you can face, argue with, even defeat, whereas despair is something that simply happens to you. So the opening suggests a slow, deliberate act of converting a feeling into an opponent.

Then the pronouns begin to slip. "Their doubtful body trust / in another" arrives out of nowhere, and the grammar is bent, since "trust" sits where we would expect "trusts" or "to trust." The line can be read as a doubtful body handing itself over to someone else, which is a fair picture of a man held up by a rope. Who "they" are is never settled. By the next stanza the figure is "he," and by the fourth it is "I," as if the Hanged Man has gradually turned into the speaker, or the reader.

The third stanza raises the stakes: "if he should suddenly die / there is nothing but what / is undercover now." "Undercover" is the slipperiest word in the poem. It can suggest spies, bedclothes, or cards lying face down, and in every case it means concealment. Read that way, if the man died now, all that would be left is whatever he has kept hidden. The line breaks help here: "nothing but what" stops on a hinge word, so we lean forward into the hidden thing before we see it.

The fourth stanza is the most thoughtful. "Is life therefore a letter from myself / which to answer I will / be accountable for." The "therefore" pretends to follow logically from what came before, though the poem has offered no argument, only images. It is a nicely human move, reaching for logic when the ground is shaky. The idea itself is striking: life as a message the self sends to itself, with a duty to reply. The syntax is stiff and inverted, like official language, and the break after "I will" is worth noticing. "Will" is a future promise, but it is also the document that matters after a death, which quietly links back to the previous stanza. That is my reading rather than something the poem states, but the line break seems to invite it. Notice, too, that this is plainly a question, yet there is no question mark. In fact there is no punctuation anywhere in the poem, so every sentence is left dangling.

The form supports this. There is no rhyme and no regular metre, just short lines in stanzas of two, two, three, three and two lines. Many lines end on weak, uncertain words ("what," "will," "wish"), so the poem sways rather than marches. The vocabulary is mostly plain and short, and then abstract words like "despair," "doubtful," "accountable" and "undercover" land with extra weight.

The ending turns on an everyday idiom. "Among other things I wish / on the cards" echoes the phrase "in the cards," meaning fated, but here wishes are placed *on* the cards, as though the speaker might nudge fate by laying hopes on the table. "Among other things" is casually offhand after such heavy questions, and that deflation feels honest. The poem stops without a full stop and leaves its wish hanging.

In just over fifty words, the poem handles despair, trust, death and responsibility without ever solving them. Its significance lies in how well its shape matches its title: a poem suspended mid-sentence, upside down, asking what we owe to the letters we send ourselves.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss