Gentrification — Poem analysis

myself becoming us becoming all the city our made light

I find my former liberty living in a fine box day and night

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six short lines, no punctuation, and one verb doing most of the work: becoming. In Dave Bonta's "Gentrification," a self spreads outward until it is the whole city, then ends up shut inside "a fine box." What first sounds like belonging turns, by the last line, into a quiet admission of loss.

The title carries a great deal, because the poem never mentions rent, money, neighbours or anyone being pushed out. All of that is left to the single word "Gentrification" and to the reader. The text gives us a speaker's position instead, and it is an uncomfortable one. Judging by the pronouns, the speaker is not the displaced resident but someone who belongs to the "us" doing the changing. "Myself" widens to "us," then to "all the city," and "our" claims ownership of what comes next. The speaker doesn't point a finger from outside. The speaker is dissolved into the process and implicated in it.

The first stanza builds this with a kind of chain. Line one ends on "us," and line two picks up with "becoming" again, as though each phrase has to grab the one before it to keep moving. There is no full stop to interrupt the growth. Then comes the shortest, strangest line: "our made light." Light that has been *made* suggests something manufactured, such as streetlamps, lit shop windows, the glow of a renovated district. The phrase also half-echoes the idiom "made light of," with the "of" missing. The reader is left to wonder what is being treated lightly, and the poem never says. That gap is one of its most effective moments, because the casual dismissal is felt without being stated.

The second stanza turns abruptly inward. "I" appears for the first time, alone after all that "us," and the line is the longest in the poem at eight syllables: "I find my former liberty." The verb "find" can mean discover, realise, or locate, and "former" tells us the liberty is already in the past. Without punctuation, the next line attaches in two ways. Either the speaker is "living in a fine box," or the liberty itself is. Both readings land in the same place, with freedom domesticated and kept indoors. "Fine" is a pleasant, approving word, and "box" is blunt and cramped. Together they make a compliment and a cage in the same breath, and the speaker never seems sure which of the two is the point.

The form supports this. The two tercets run roughly six, seven and three syllables, then eight, six and three, and each ends on a clipped three-syllable line. Those endings are the poem's only rhyme: "light" and "night." The pairing is ironic. Light and night are normally opposites, but "day and night" removes the difference, and the box is simply constant. The glow the speaker helped to make and the enclosure the speaker lives in come to feel like one fact. The stanzas also move in opposite directions. The first expands from a person to "all the city," and the second contracts from a "liberty" to a box. The poem enlarges the speaker and then shrinks them, and the closing line is almost flat in tone.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it won't preach. It could have been an angry piece about outsiders and developers, but it speaks from inside the change, in a voice that sounds calm, even comfortable, and slightly stunned. It suggests that gentrification isn't only something done to a place. People take part in it by becoming "us," and the price may be the very freedom that drew them there. The poem says all this in six lines and leaves the reader to put in the streets, the prices and the neighbours.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.