Sturm und drang — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

light up to see in a dark room

while the tempest sings a most excellent music

a dark pleasure this blood I bleed out

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six short lines, no punctuation, no capital letters, and a storm somewhere in the middle: Dave Bonta's "Sturm und drang" is tiny, but it makes a whole argument about what to do with pain. The title borrows the German phrase for "storm and stress," the name of a late eighteenth-century German literary movement known for extreme feeling. Bonta then does the opposite of bombast. Instead of thunder, he gives us a quiet room, a light, and a speaker who sounds strangely calm about bleeding.

The poem moves through three two-line stanzas, and each seems to belong to a different sense. The first is sight: "light up to see / in a dark room." The phrasing is slippery. With no subject, it can read as a command or as a purpose ("I light up in order to see"). "Light up" might mean switching on a lamp, but it also suggests something catching fire inside the speaker. Either way the room stays "dark." The light is a small act of defiance, not a cure.

The second stanza is hearing: "while the tempest sings / a most excellent music." Personifying the storm as a singer turns weather into performance, and the speaker becomes its audience. "Tempest" is a grander, more bookish word than "storm," and "most excellent" has an old-fashioned courtliness, as if the speaker were complimenting a musician at a concert. The politeness is nearly comic against the violence outside, and it is the poem's first hint that this speaker has made peace with turbulence.

The third stanza turns to the body: "a dark pleasure / this blood I bleed out." The repeated word "dark" links this stanza back to the first, so the pleasure seems to belong to the darkness rather than to exist in spite of it. The demonstrative "this" makes the speaker sound like someone holding out a handful of blood for us to look at. The poem never says whether the blood is literal or figurative. Judging by the way it follows the singing storm, it is tempting to read the bleeding as making art, so that the poem itself is what gets bled out. But "bleed out" also suggests draining and loss, and the poem lets that unease sit beside the word "pleasure" without explanation.

The sound of the poem supports this reading. There is no rhyme, so nothing clicks shut at the end. The lines are short, running from four to six syllables, and the middle stanza is the longest and most fluid. "A most excellent music" glides on soft m sounds and open vowels, so it is the one moment where the language itself sounds musical, matching what it describes. The final line then tightens into monosyllables. "This blood I bleed out" has heavy stresses on "blood," "bleed," and "out," and the repeated b is a plosive that lands like a drip or a thud. With no full stop, the poem seems to drain away instead of concluding.

The poem is significant for how much it does with so little. The movement named in the title is associated with emotional excess, yet Bonta compresses that excess into something close to a whisper, and the result is arguably more unsettling than a shout. The poem also leaves a real question open for readers. Is the speaker's pleasure honest, a way of turning suffering into something beautiful? Or is it a pose, a way of staying composed while hurting? Because the poem never answers, each reader has to decide whether the light in the dark room is comfort or just enough illumination to watch the bleeding.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.