Orchard — Poem analysis

a field of orange and lemon trees by the house

like the whole body to a hand

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Five short lines, no verb and no punctuation, and still Dave Bonta turns a view into a puzzle. The first stanza is something you could say while pointing from a doorway: "a field of orange / and lemon trees / by the house." The second stanza, after a gap, is where the poem stops being simple: "like the whole body / to a hand." On the surface this is about a house and the land beside it, but the comparison asks which of the two is the main thing and which is only a part.

The first stanza is built from ordinary, bright things. Orange and lemon are two citrus names, two colours, perhaps two flavours, sweet and sharp, set side by side with a plain "and." The word "field" is a slightly unexpected choice for trees. It suggests open ground and cultivation, as if the orchard were a crop rather than a collection of individual plants. The house arrives last, tucked into the phrase "by the house" almost as an afterthought. Notice also that the word "orchard" appears only in the title. The poem never says it, so the title names what the lines then describe, and the reader sees the thing before hearing its name.

Then comes the simile, and its grammar is strange. "Like the whole body to a hand" is a proportion with its verb missing, so we have to supply one. Read one way, it is about closeness: the orchard sits by the house as intimately as a body is joined to a hand, so the two cannot really be separated. Read another way, it is about scale and importance. The house becomes the hand, a small part that reaches out, and the orchard becomes the whole body that the hand belongs to. That reverses the usual order, in which the house is the centre of a human life and the land around it is scenery. The imagery of fruit gives a third possibility, since hands are what pick oranges and lemons, so the house may be the part of the body that touches and gathers. These readings are inferences, and the poem doesn't choose between them. The articles help: "the whole body" is definite and complete, while "a hand" is any hand, one part among many.

The sound of the poem quietly supports the idea. "House," "whole" and "hand" all begin with an h, and they are spread across the two stanzas so that the first stanza's last noun and the second stanza's last noun echo each other. The comparison is made in sound before the meaning is worked out. There is no rhyme, and the poem doesn't need one. The rhythm comes from the lines shrinking and swelling. Counting syllables roughly, the lines run five, four, three, then five and three again. The first stanza narrows toward "house," the second repeats the pattern, and the poem ends on the short, heavy monosyllable "hand," which stops like a closing fist. With no full stop and no capital letters, the thought feels open at the edges, as if the comparison were still going on after the poem ends.

The white space between stanzas carries a lot of weight. It works like a pause for breath, or like looking at the orchard and then looking down at your own hand. The poem gives us a landscape in the first half and a body in the second, and the stanza break is where one turns into the other. The orchard is no longer just beside the house but is felt as something with limbs, an organism. That is a judgement drawn from the imagery rather than anything the poem states, but the word "body" invites it.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it does with how little. It doesn't explain its metaphor or tell us how to feel about citrus trees. It gives us a small, concrete scene and one odd comparison, and it trusts us to feel the shift in scale. After reading it, "by the house" no longer sounds like a casual location. It sounds like a relationship in which the house is the smaller part, reaching out from something much larger.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss