Sundown — Poem analysis

all day in the park where a man cannot live

but can get wine and bark at a fox

making accommodation for the dark

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dusk in Dave Bonta's "Sundown" is less a pretty sky than a deadline. The poem is six short lines, a single unpunctuated sentence, yet it holds a whole day. It starts with "all day in the park" and ends on the word "dark." Between those points a man does very little, and the poem is about exactly that little: what a person does with his hours in a place where, as the second line flatly puts it, he "cannot live."

That phrase is the hinge, and it is ambiguous in a useful way. Is living in the park forbidden, or is a park simply not a home, with no walls and no roof? The poem doesn't say. Judging by the details (a full day outdoors, wine, the approach of night), a reader may picture someone with nowhere else to go. But the poem never uses the word "homeless" and never asks for pity. The generic "a man," rather than "I" or a named person, turns one figure into a type and keeps the speaker at a cool distance, like a naturalist noting what a species can and cannot do.

The second couplet is a short, odd ledger: "but can get wine / and bark at a fox." The "but" promises compensation for the impossibility of living in the park, and what arrives is bleakly funny. Wine is the available comfort, and barking is the available activity. Barking is a dog's job, guarding territory, so the man takes up the role even though he has no territory to guard. He aims it at the fox, which, unlike him, can live in the park. Foxes also make barking calls, so the scene may be closer to a conversation than a quarrel, two creatures calling across a gap at the end of the day. The poem leaves that open.

The sound ties these images together. "Park," "bark" and "dark" share one hard vowel and the same closing consonants, and they fall at the end of the first line, inside the fourth, and at the very end. The place, the man's one gesture and the coming night are chained by sound, and the bark sits between park and dark as if noise were the only thing he could set against either. Most of the vocabulary is plain and one-syllable: "day," "man," "live," "wine," "fox."

The exception is "accommodation." The lines run roughly five, six, four, five, seven and three syllables, so line five is the longest and contains the poem's only long word. It is official language, the vocabulary of hotels and committees, and it carries two meanings at once. Accommodation is lodging, which the man lacks. It is also adjustment or compromise, which is what he can offer instead. Denied the first, he makes the second. The line also reverses the usual roles. The man without a place to stay makes room for the dark, as though it were a guest arriving after a long day.

Then the poem shrinks to "for the dark," three syllables with two light beats and a heavy final one. It stops like a door closing. The participle "making" also dangles grammatically. It isn't clearly attached to anyone, so we can't tell whether the man is adjusting, the park is, or the evening itself is. The lowercase, punctuation-free lines add to this drift. The pause after "all day in the park" leaves the day sitting alone for a moment before the complication of line two arrives.

The title adds a final turn. "Sundown" names the hour, but the word never appears in the text, and the poem only reaches it at its last word, "dark." The reader waits through the day alongside the man.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it fits into so few words. It is closer in size to a haiku than to a traditional lyric, yet it holds a social observation, a joke and a mood. It refuses sentimentality. The man is not a victim in a poster; he drinks, barks and adjusts, and the poem treats those small acts with a straight face that lets their dignity and absurdity show together. Without arguing the point, it raises the question of who gets to be at home where, and it leaves us at dusk with the park emptying and the dark coming in.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.