Outer self — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

to give like the grave our outer self

a thin king of the afternoon

that mission in which I do not believe

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six lines, three couplets and not one full stop: Dave Bonta's "Outer self" offers very little to hold, and that is why it leaves so much to turn over. It is about what happens to the surface of a person (the body, the face, the role we present to the world) when it is handed over to death. It is also about the speaker's refusal to feel certain or solemn about that handover. The central idea is a quiet scepticism. Even while imagining the surrender of the self, the speaker will not endorse any grand purpose that might justify it.

The poem begins mid-thought, in lowercase, with an infinitive that has no subject: "to give like the grave / our outer self." The syntax is slippery. A grave is a place that receives and keeps, so it is odd to hear it described as giving. One reading is that we should hand over our outer self as completely as a grave takes a body. Another is that the grave is itself a giver, soil that yields and makes room. The poem does not choose between them. Sound pairs the words before sense does: "give" and "grave" share a hard *g* and a closing *v*, so a warm verb and a cold noun lock together by ear. The word "outer" matters too. It implies an inner self that stays behind, but the poem never mentions one. We are told what is surrendered and nothing about what remains.

The second couplet supplies the only real image: "a thin king / of the afternoon." If the outer self is a king, it is the public part of us, with its crown, its authority and its costume. But "thin" drains the grandeur at once. This is a king with little substance, ruling a kingdom of borrowed hours. Afternoon is past the height of noon and already tilting towards evening, so the reign is shrinking. Judging by the imagery, a reader might also picture a shadow, long and narrow in late light, which is the most "outer" thing about anyone and the thing that stretches furthest just before it vanishes. The poem does not say so, but the picture fits. The phrase "thin king" has a chime of short *i* and *ng* sounds, the nearest the poem comes to rhyme, and it falls on the most mock-royal phrase in the text.

Then comes the turn: "that mission in which / I do not believe." The word "that" points backward without saying exactly where. It might mean the giving, the kingship, or the whole business of having a self to give up. "Mission" suggests a sending-out on an errand larger than oneself, with religious or military overtones. The line break after "in which" leaves the sentence hanging on a preposition, and the reader waits. Then the weight lands on "I do not believe." This is the only first-person statement in the poem and its only complete, finite-verb clause. Everything before it is infinitive, fragment or image, and when the grammar finally firms up, what it says is a refusal. The pronoun shifts as well, from the shared "our" of the opening to a single, private "I." The fate is common, but the dissent belongs to one voice.

The poem's shape supports this. Apart from the three-syllable "a thin king," every line runs four or five syllables. The short, even lines give a steady, almost ritual pulse, which suits a poem about a solemn subject. The shortest line holds the thinnest figure, so the king is thin even on the page. There is no end rhyme, but the poem is stitched by echo. The short *i* sound runs through "give," "thin," "king," "mission," "in" and "which," and "give" at the start answers "believe" at the end with the same closing sound. The movement from one to the other is the poem's whole arc, from offering to withholding assent.

What makes "Outer self" worth reading is its restraint. Poems about death and the self often console or lament. This one does neither. It sketches the surrender of the self, gives it a faintly comic, diminished king, and then declines to sign up for the cause. The missing full stop means even that disbelief stays open. In under twenty words it shows how much doubt a short poem can hold.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss