Journalism — Poem analysis

lying with my journal for days

a hot sandwich of security and regret

in the evening quiet I confess my ruin

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Lying is the poem's first and most slippery word. In "lying with my journal / for days," the speaker is reclining, probably idle, perhaps in bed, but the verb also carries its other meaning: telling untruths. The phrase "lying with" even borrows the vocabulary of intimacy, as if the journal were a bedfellow. In six short lines, Dave Bonta sets up a question that the rest of the poem never settles: when we write about ourselves, are we being honest or hiding? His answer seems to be that we do both, and that the two feel very alike from the inside.

The title does a lot of quiet work. "Journalism" normally means reporting facts to the public, yet here the only reader is the speaker's own private notebook. The word swells a small, secret habit into a grand profession, and that mismatch is faintly comic. There is also a buried link between "journal" and "days," since the word comes from the French *jour*, "day." The poem enacts it: the journal is the thing that records days, and the speaker has spent "days" with it, so the time passes in the very book meant to capture it.

The middle couplet is the strangest and most memorable. "A hot sandwich / of security and regret" turns two abstract feelings into slices of something edible. A sandwich has layers and a filling, and the speaker seems to be the filling, pressed between safety and remorse. The "security" might be the comfort of staying put, of never leaving the room or the page. The "regret" is what that safety costs. The word "hot" does a lot in a small space. It suggests comfort food, but also stuffiness, a closed room, a fever. The image is domestic and almost silly, which keeps the poem from sounding self-pitying even as the feeling underneath it is bleak. It is also hard to say whether the speaker wants to eat this sandwich or is simply stuck holding it.

Then the register changes. "In the evening quiet / I confess my ruin" moves from kitchen language to the language of church or courtroom. "Confess" implies a listener, and the only one present is the journal, which now plays priest as well as bedfellow. "Ruin" is a big, almost theatrical word, set against the humble sandwich and the quiet room. We can read it two ways. It may be a real admission of a wasted or damaged life. It may be an overstatement, the dramatic flourish of someone who knows that journals invite exaggeration. The poem gives no sign which, and that uncertainty is part of its honesty. Having already played on the idea of lying, it makes us wonder whether this confession can be trusted.

The construction is spare. There are three couplets, no rhyme, no punctuation and no capital letters, so the lines seem to drift rather than declare. The line lengths are uneven, and the short "for days" hangs like a pause, giving the idea of time passing a physical stretch of white space. Each couplet also ends on a heavier word than the last: "days," then "regret," then "ruin." The poem slides from duration to feeling to catastrophe, and it stops on the harshest note without comment. Sound helps tie the poem to its speaker. The long *i* of "lying," "my," "quiet" and "I" keeps returning, and the possessives ("my journal," "my ruin") remind us that everything here is enclosed in one person's view. The soft hiss of "sandwich," "security" and "confess" gives the middle and end a hushed, whispering quality, fitting for a confession.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it holds in so little room. It is close in brevity to a haiku, though it does not follow a fixed syllable pattern, and like a good short poem it works by compression: one pun, one odd image and one change of tone. It also catches something true about private writing, that a journal can be refuge and trap at once, a place to be honest and a place to stall. The speaker lies with the journal, lies to it, perhaps lies *in* it, and still comes to it in the evening quiet to say the hardest thing. That the confession arrives so plainly, after such a strange sandwich, is what lingers.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.