In hac spe vivo — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

the wren gives me small hopes

but I can hear the sea a prophesy of love

some parts very good others devilish

and me alone with the world

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Twenty-eight words, four couplets, and a Latin title that promises something grander than the poem delivers. «In hac spe vivo» means "In this hope I live," which sounds like a motto carved over a doorway. Dave Bonta then spends eight short lines showing what that hope looks like in practice: a bird, a sound of water, a mixed verdict on the day, and a speaker on his own. The gap between the solemn title and the plain, offhand voice is where the poem lives.

Its central idea is that hope does not have to be large to be livable. The first couplet is almost a correction of the title. The wren "gives me / small hopes," and the adjective matters. A wren is a tiny bird, and the gift it brings is scaled to match. The word "gives" makes hope something received from the world, not something the speaker manufactures. The title says "this hope," singular and definite, but the poem offers hopes in the plural, small and scattered. It suggests that a life can be held up by several modest things rather than one great belief.

Then comes the turn: "but I can hear the sea / a prophesy of love." The "but" is interesting because it doesn't contradict the wren. It adds to it, as if the speaker looks up from the small thing and notices something enormous in the background. The sea is heard, not seen, so it reaches him as sound, like the bird. A prophecy is also a statement about the future, which means love has been promised, not delivered. The poem uses the spelling "prophesy," the form usually kept for the verb, and the word seems to act as well as name. The sea is almost doing the prophesying as he listens. The line break after "sea" lets the image sit for a beat before the poem explains it, and the explanation is oddly stated, with no punctuation and no fuss.

The third couplet changes tone. "Some parts very good / others devilish" sounds like someone assessing a day, a walk, a stretch of life, or even a draft of a poem. The poem never says what the "parts" belong to, and that vagueness is deliberate. The phrasing is colloquial, close to a shrug. "Devilish" is the most surprising word. It is half-serious, half-playful, nowhere near the weight of "evil" or "damned," yet it brings the devil quietly into a poem whose title belongs to the language of prayer. The speaker admits that the bad parts exist without letting them turn tragic. That honesty makes the hope more believable, because it has survived an accounting.

The last couplet, "and me alone / with the world," narrows everything to a single figure. The poem moves in scale as it goes, from the wren to the sea to the "parts" of experience to the world itself. The word "alone" could read as loneliness, but "with the world" complicates it. He is not alone *in* the world but alone *with* it, which suggests company of a strange kind. The poem leaves the preposition ambiguous. The world might be his companion, his opponent, or simply the thing he has to face.

Formally, the poem is free verse. It has no capital letters, no punctuation and no regular meter, only short lines of two to six words. A hidden rhyme still ties it together: "me" at the end of the first line and "sea" at the end of the third answer each other across the gap, linking the bird's gift to the ocean's prophecy. "Me" returns in the final couplet as "and me alone," so the speaker bookends the poem. The sounds are soft throughout, with the long *o* in "hopes," "alone" and "world" and the *s* sounds of "small," "sea" and "devilish." The lack of a full stop at the end leaves the thought open, as if the poem simply stops where the speaker's attention does.

The poem matters because it makes a large word like hope believable by shrinking it to the size of a bird. It spends little effort on grand claims and relies on a few exact images, a deflating bit of slang and an honest ending. Like many very short poems, it trusts the reader to supply what the speaker leaves out. The title says how he lives, and the poem shows how small that foundation can be and how much it can still hold.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss