Darkness at noon — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

a hanging at noon many fine people there

going and coming make me unable to read myself

two lines together grow a night

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Barely two dozen words long, "Darkness at noon" manages to hold a public killing, a crowd, a crisis of self-knowledge and a small theory of how poems work. It begins with the plainest possible report: "a hanging at noon / many fine people there." Nothing in the tone reacts to the event. The hanging is stated, and the next line moves on to the attendance, as a newspaper might note who turned up. The phrase "many fine people" carries the chill. "Fine" could be the speaker's irony, or it could be the crowd's own opinion of itself. Either way, it sets respectability beside violence and lets the two sit there without comment. The noon of the title adds to this: daylight, the hour of ordinary business, with nothing hidden.

The second couplet turns inward. "Going and coming / make me unable to read myself." The crowd's restless traffic, people arriving and leaving as if the hanging were a market or a procession, unsettles the speaker's sense of who he is. The verb "read" is the surprising choice. He does not say he cannot know or face himself. He says he cannot read himself, as if he were a page that has stopped making sense. Reading also involves eyes moving back and forth along lines, so "going and coming" may describe the crowd and the act of reading at once. The speaker is watching people, and the poem is watching itself. There is a quiet question of complicity here too. If he is among the fine people, what does that make him? The poem never says, and the missing answer is part of what unsettles.

The last couplet is the boldest: "two lines together / grow a night." The speaker's "two lines" could be the two opening lines, the hanging and the pleasant crowd, which are harmless alone and darken once they stand side by side. Or they could be any two lines of writing, so that the poem is describing its own method. Putting one thing next to another makes a meaning bigger than either. The verb "grow" matters. Night is not switched on or dropped; it grows, like something organic, from the contact between the lines. That fits the title. The darkness at noon is neither an eclipse nor weather. It is made by language and by juxtaposition, and it is moral. The title may faintly recall the Gospel accounts of darkness falling over the land at midday during a crucifixion. That is an inference, since the poem never mentions it, but a public execution, a watching crowd and a noon darkness make the echo hard to ignore.

The construction is bare. There are three couplets with no punctuation, no capital letters and no rhyme. The absence of full stops means the poem has no clear moment where one thought ends and the next begins, so the images seem to seep into each other, which suits a poem about lines growing together. The rhythm is plain and spoken, built on short phrases like "a hanging at noon" and "grow a night." The longest line, "make me unable to read myself," stretches out just as the speaker's confidence in himself falters, and the final two lines then contract to a blunt three-word ending. There is also some quiet sound-play. "Noon" and "two" share a long vowel, and "going," "coming" and "grow" keep a rounded, falling sound that feels almost like dusk gathering in the voice. Because no line rhymes, nothing comforts the ear, and that suits a poem that refuses comfort.

What makes the poem significant is how much it trusts the reader. It supplies no details of who was hanged or why, and no moral lesson. It gives three small, calm statements and lets the dark build from the gaps between them. In that sense the poem acts out its own last sentence: the reader joins the two lines together and finds the night growing in their own head. For a student, it is a good example of how a very short poem can be unsettling through what it leaves out, and how plain words, placed carefully, can carry a heavy charge.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.