the girl i saw on the mirror — Poem analysis

EllaSad

she took the painkiller and drank a bottle of water thought all the screams that stuck on her head would go away as she laid on bed her eyes were so black and her soul was pale blue she was there, alone in the dark but not a single body knew she smiled, but ripped she kept all the wounds, and not ever lived

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Ella is a girl who hurts and cannot say so. In ten short lines the poem follows her through a single night in bed. She swallows a painkiller, drinks a bottle of water, and hopes that "all the screams that stuck on her head / would go away." We never learn what the screams are, and that silence is the poem's method. Its central idea is the gap between what people can see and what a person carries. A smile is visible, but the wounds are kept out of sight, and "not a single body knew."

The subtitle, «the girl i saw on the mirror», changes how we read everything after it. The poem is told in the third person and the past tense, as if the speaker were watching someone else. Yet a mirror shows us ourselves, so Ella may be the speaker's own reflection, or someone seen so closely that she feels like a double. Either way the poem builds distance into its telling: she is observed, not heard, and she never speaks. The title adds a small coincidence. "Ella" is a name, and it is also the Spanish word for "she." Whether or not that was intended, it fits a girl who is reduced to a pronoun in the poem's own eyes.

The opening relies on ordinary objects. A painkiller and a bottle of water are the tools of a headache, and that is the quiet irony. Ella treats an invisible pain as if it were a physical one. The poem never says whether the pill is a modest remedy or something darker, and the reader has to live with that uncertainty. The verb "stuck" turns screams, which should be fleeting sounds, into something that clings. Lines 3 and 4 give the poem its first clear rhyme, "head" and "bed." The click is almost soothing, like a lullaby. But "bed" is also where she stays, and the comfort proves false. The first two lines end more loosely, with "painkiller" and "water" echoing each other in their unstressed final syllables.

The middle of the poem turns from action to description, and colour does the work. "Her eyes were so black / and her soul was pale blue" are two lines of almost identical length, set side by side like the two halves of a reflection. Black is heavy, tired, perhaps bruised. Pale blue is cold, faded, drained of blood. The body is dark and the soul is washed out, and neither is warm. The next line, "alone in the dark," picks up "black" again, so the darkness seems to close around her. The rhyme of "blue" and "knew" stretches across a line that ends in "dark," as though connection is being attempted and interrupted. The word "body" is also odd where we might expect "one" or "person." Her soul has just been mentioned, and now nobody, not even a body, is paying attention.

The last two lines are the sharpest. "She smiled, but ripped" leaves out a word. Ripped what? The missing "was" makes her seem torn like paper or cloth, a smile stretched over a split. Then comes the longest line of the poem, "she kept all the wounds, and not ever lived." "Kept" makes the wounds sound like possessions she hoards and guards. "Not ever lived" is more awkward than "never lived," and the awkwardness slows it down and makes it heavier. It can mean that she never truly lived, or that keeping the wounds took the place of living. The poem ends on "lived," but the word is negated, so the ending is a verdict on a life, not a hope. "Ripped" and "lived" share only a clipped final consonant, and the poem closes without the click of a rhyme.

Plain language and loose grammar ("laid on bed," no capital letters, almost no punctuation) give the poem the feel of something written quickly and privately. That is an impression from the text, not a fact about how it was made. It suits the subject. A polished, ornate style would feel wrong for a girl who has nobody to perform for.

The poem matters because of its restraint. It gives no cause, no villain and no rescue, only a few images exact enough to recognise: the pill, the dark, the smile that doesn't match the inside. It asks readers to notice what a mirror, or a friend, might easily miss.

Read also

More by Ella

All poems
ContemplativeElla

* * *

they were things that my lips could never say. they were stories i was always afraid to tell. they were the unspoken.
ContemplativeElla

what the night wind told me

the night wind told me something in the fork under the yellow dull lamp street he said to me : "your cold is not my cold.
SadElla

i like it when it rains hard

And in the street people stop and take shelter I like it when it rains hard And I watch it through my window I like it when it rains hard