love — Poem analysis

once upon a time I knew a boy who loved drawing magnificent paintings that nobody saw,

he used to draw by himself alone at night locked in a smoke filled bedroom where no one but he could see the paintings looked strange they were twisted

his brush was a razor his canvas, a wrist

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The poem opens like a fairy tale, "once upon a time I knew a boy", and for six lines it keeps up the pretence. We meet a gifted, solitary artist who makes "magnificent paintings / that nobody saw". Only the last two lines show what the story has been hiding: "his brush was a razor / his canvas, a wrist." The poem is about self-harm, and about how easily it stays out of sight. Its central idea is that suffering can be secret, even aestheticised, and that the people nearby may notice nothing.

Everything depends on the extended metaphor of the last couplet, which turns the earlier lines inside out. Until then, "drawing" and "paintings" seem harmless, even admirable. Once we reach the razor and the wrist, we reread. "Magnificent" now sounds uneasy, as if the boy, or the speaker remembering him, can't help describing the act in the language of art. The poem never names blood or pain. It leaves the colour of those "paintings" to the reader, which is more disturbing than description would be.

The poem keeps returning to seeing. The paintings are ones "nobody saw", made in a place "where no one but he could see", and they "looked strange". Saw, see, looked: the repetition makes the boy's isolation almost physical, and the poem's real subject becomes what goes unseen. The bedroom is "locked" and "smoke filled", so it is closed, airless and private. The phrase "alone at night" adds to this. The reader is let into the room at the end, which makes us the first audience the boy's "work" has had. That is an uncomfortable position, and the poem seems to intend it.

"Twisted" is the key word of the middle stanza, and it works on two levels. It describes the distorted look of the paintings, but it also hints at a troubled inner state, a mind or feeling bent out of shape. The poem doesn't explain this. It also rhymes quietly with the final word, "wrist", through the shared *-ist* sound. In a poem with no regular rhyme, that echo links the strange pictures to their cause. We might not notice it consciously, but it helps the ending feel inevitable.

The form is spare free verse. There are no capital letters, almost no punctuation (one comma after "saw", then nothing), and short lines of uneven length. The three stanzas run to four lines, six lines, then two, so the poem breaks off just when it has said the most. The lowercase, unpunctuated style suits the subject. It sounds quiet and flat, like someone telling a painful thing without raising their voice. The final lines have the same grammar, but the second drops its verb: "his brush *was* a razor / his canvas, a wrist." That small gap, marked only by a comma, is where the horror sits. Like the boy's actions, the sentence leaves out what it cannot bear to say.

The speaker's position is also worth noticing. "I knew a boy" keeps the subject at arm's length, and the past tense ("loved", "used to draw") gives the whole poem a retrospective, perhaps mournful feel. The text doesn't say whether this boy is a separate person or a mask for the speaker, and we shouldn't claim to know. Judging by the opening, though, the fairy-tale phrasing may be a way of making something unbearable easier to tell, a story told because the plain truth is too hard.

The title, "love", set in lowercase, adds another layer. The boy "loved" drawing, but the poem leaves us wondering what else is meant. It might be the absence of love, or care that never reached him, or love turned into something destructive. The poem doesn't settle this, and the ambiguity is part of its force.

What makes the poem significant is how much it does in so few words. It doesn't lecture or describe, and it doesn't use shock for its own sake. It uses a familiar image, the lonely artist, and lets the reader discover its darker meaning. The lasting effect is a question: who might be making "paintings" that nobody sees? Poems on this subject are worth discussing carefully, and if this one feels close to home, talking to someone you trust is a good place to start.

Read also

More by EmiliaPettersson

All poems
SadEmiliaPettersson

(e.j.p)

Nothing is bright anymore, everything is just bland. I see no colours anymore, all I see is grey. Nothing exites me anymore, it's as if my heartbeat don't exist. I'm low, it's dark, it's familiar.
RomanticEmiliaPettersson

(e.j.p)

Your fingerprints are attached to my skin, burning my body. My body feeding of of it.
AnxiousEmiliaPettersson

(e.j.p)

i'm slightly broken, crushed, more void then human. liquid fills the cracks, smoke blurres the lines, music shake the pieces. bathroom tiles hazy, light flickering to the beat of my heart, and i swear i see him. behind me with the red eyes and a killing pin between his lips. cracked hands running through my hair, smiling at me like every part of his shattered soul were lying in my hands. bathroom tiles still hazy, light still flickering, heart still beating. he has my soul, too