Not Clear — Poem analysis

It is not clear what if anything we will leave behind

for whom, what for, how long- it is not clear if we will have the right.

Instead, even the rain stops falling for a while and filters through the cracks

drops do drip and drip, brown into a marmalade jar, bricks rotting away

(since the distant past)

Everybody is out and about and you are cocooned, indoors shrouded by sirens, and echoes.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

"It is not clear" is how Ernesto Priego's poem begins, and it is nearly all the speaker will promise. The phrase returns a few lines later, like someone pressing a bruise to see if it still hurts. The poem is a short meditation on legacy and permanence: what, if anything, we leave behind, and whether we even have the right to. Its central idea is that uncertainty about the future is not abstract. It seeps into ordinary rooms, through a leak, a jar and a wall, and into the person sitting indoors.

Look at how the questions are built. "for whom, what for, how long" is a run of questions with no question marks, cut off by a dash before the thought can settle. Then comes the most unsettling line: "if we will have the right." The right to what? The sentence never says. It might be the right to be remembered, to leave something, to go on existing. The missing object is the point, because we feel an entitlement being doubted before we learn what it was.

Then "Instead." It is a strange connective, since the poem never says instead of what. Perhaps instead of answers, we get weather. Rain is usually the picture of something that carries on regardless, so when "even the rain / stops falling for a while," the world feels suspended. Yet the pause brings no dryness, because the water "filters through the cracks." The poem moves from sky to interior, from a large question to a small domestic problem. The sound arrives with it: "drops do drip and drip." That little "do" is almost defiant, as if answering someone who claimed the dripping had stopped, and the doubled "drip" has the monotony of a leak heard at night. "Brown" sits alone at the line break before we know what it describes, and the dirty colour stains what follows.

Then the jar. A marmalade jar is homely and slightly comic, and it is the best touch in the poem. It is made to preserve fruit, sweetness, a season, and here it has been drafted as a makeshift bucket for filthy water. The impulse to keep things safe, which the first stanza worries over on a human scale, is quietly mocked by the object itself. Next come "bricks rotting away." We trust bricks to outlast us, and rot belongs to wood and fruit, so letting bricks rot makes even the sturdiest structure subject to time. The bracketed line "(since the distant past)" is the poem's smallest stanza and its quietest. The parentheses make it sound like an aside, yet it stretches the timeline backwards almost without limit. The decay is not new, and "how long" has already been answered with an indifferent "far longer than you think."

The last stanza shifts from "we" to "you." "Everybody is out and about" has the breezy ease of a cliché, and that casualness isolates the person left inside. "Cocooned" suggests warmth, protection, even the possibility of change. Two words later, "shrouded" is a burial cloth. The poem lets the two pull against each other and does not choose. What wraps this person is not fabric but sound: "sirens, and echoes." The comma before "and echoes" lets the last word arrive like an afterthought, a noise repeating after its cause has gone. The poem never says why "you" are indoors. Judging by the imagery it could be illness, fear or a long stretch of waiting, and that openness lets readers bring their own circumstances to it.

Formally, the poem is free verse in tercets, with one single line interrupting the pattern. There is no rhyme and no steady beat. Short lines and enjambment ("rain / stops falling," "brown / into") make the sense spill over, much as the water does. Sound does some of the work rhyme might have done: the insistent d of "drops do drip and drip," and the hard k of "cracks," "cocooned" and "echoes."

What makes the poem worth reading is its restraint. It asks about legacy, a grand and solemn subject, and answers with a jar and a wall. The answer is not comforting, since nothing is guaranteed to last, not even brick. But there is a stubborn attentiveness here too, because someone is listening closely enough to count each drop. In a poem so unsure of what will survive, that act of noticing may be the one thing that is clearly ours.

Read also

More by Ernesto Priego

All poems
DreamyErnesto Priego

El caballito

We took for granted the good weather we did not think of it the grass grew beneath our feet between the cracks of ladrillos
SadErnesto Priego

Coney Island

Over the photograph of the whole beach (the abandoned amusement park behind), a lonely bird. The next photograph shows the bird,