Gabe's "Into You" is a confession from someone in love with a friend. The speaker kissed their cheek, admitted to being the friend's first, and now regrets how obvious their feelings have become. They read kindness as a sign of romance, then remind themselves that caring is just what friends do. "My intuition, I need to stop listening" shows how much they doubt their own hopes.
The feeling here is mostly ache. The speaker feels lonely when the friend leaves, and when the friend sits close, their heart "shatters," because they suspect the other person's heart "won't beat the same." Still, the poem ends in tenderness rather than bitterness. The speaker asks the friend not to become "a new stranger," and promises to keep caring even if the friend finds a lover. The last line, "I love you," is plain and unguarded. The mood is vulnerable, quietly hopeful, and a little afraid of being left behind.