wishing from the stars — Poem analysis

hansSad

i wish i could be there for you when you go through hard times. eventhough we're not always talking to each other anymore, & eventhough we, didn't own each other.

i wish you can let me know, if there's one day you don't feel fine at all when you're at your lowest

and when you ever need me i hope you know i'm always there.

it's just now, i seem to be in silence because i know i'm not needed.

-i wish i can rely onto you like that too, i wish i can.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Hans's «wishing from the stars» begins as a promise and ends as a confession. For most of the poem the speaker offers comfort: *I wish I could be there for you*, *let me know* if you are at your lowest, *I'm always there*. Then the generosity turns around, and what we hear is the speaker's own need, to lean on someone in return. The central idea is the loneliness of being ready to care for a person who doesn't seem to want that care, and the hope that support might one day run in both directions.

The title sets the mood before the first line. The poem never mentions stars, so the image has to work on its own, and the most natural reading is that it suggests distance. We make wishes on stars when we can't reach what we want, and stars don't answer back. That fits a speaker who stands far from the other person and can only wish.

"Wish" is the poem's key word. It opens the first stanza (*i wish i could*), opens the second (*i wish you can*), and appears twice in the last two lines. Its grammar shifts as the poem goes on. The first wish is conditional, "could", an admission that the speaker is currently unable to help. By the end it is a bare "can": *i wish i can rely onto you like that too, / i wish i can.* The repetition, with its full stop and nothing after it, sounds like someone repeating a hope more quietly because they doubt it will come true. Against all this wishing, the only flat statement of fact in the speaker's offer is *i'm always there*, and it sits in a stanza of just three lines, calm and steady.

The form works the same way. There is no rhyme and no regular beat, so the poem sounds like spoken thought, or a message typed and not quite polished. The lowercase letters, the hurried ampersand, and phrases like "eventhough" and "rely onto" add to that unguarded feel. The stanzas also shrink, from six lines to four, then three, three, and finally two. The poem seems to draw inward as it goes, like a person who starts a conversation openly and gradually runs out of things they feel allowed to say.

The first stanza holds the poem's most hesitant moment. *& eventhough we,* breaks off on a comma before the thought finishes: *didn't own each other.* That pause reads like a speaker choosing their words carefully. The statement is a kind of defence. By saying they never owned each other, the speaker gives up any claim to the other person's time or trust. The trouble is that this also removes any right to ask for anything back. Freedom and loneliness turn out to be the same fact seen from two sides.

The last stanza before the final lines is where the poem becomes most honest. *it's just now, / i seem to be in silence / because i know i'm not needed.* "Just" tries to make the confession small, as if it hardly matters. "Seem" and "know" pull in different directions. The speaker only *seems* to be silent, as if the silence were a place they had drifted into, but they claim to *know* they're unneeded. That certainty sounds more like a conclusion drawn from pain than a fact anyone has actually stated, and the poem never shows the other person saying it. The dash that opens the final lines, *-i wish i can rely onto you*, works like a slip: the thought escapes before it can be tidied away.

There is also a quiet irony in the middle of the poem. The speaker keeps imagining the other person *at your lowest*, yet the poem slowly shows that the speaker may be at a low point too, with no one to tell. Care is offered as a gift, but it is also the only way the speaker can say how much they would like to be cared for.

The poem matters because it is so plain about something people rarely say aloud. Many of us have been the one who keeps the door open, and many of us have felt that this kind of availability can be a form of waiting. Hans gives that feeling no grand imagery. The poem's strength lies in small choices: a stanza that shrinks, a wish that loses its "could", a silence the speaker claims to understand and plainly hopes to be wrong about.

Read also

More by hans

All poems
Sadhans

night

why did you always saying such a hurtful things to me, not knowing
Contemplativehans

option

i was always an option in everyone's life while i myself
Romantichans

i like you for that

you may not know this but i like you so much for things that maybe others didnt like you