Never say the L word. — Poem analysis

Safe over sorry, Lost over loved; These are the choices, I've had to make, Because it's easier to catch rain in a cup than on the tip of your tongue.

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A harbor keeps ships safe, but a ship that never leaves it isn't doing what ships are for. Both ideas sit inside the title. "Harbor" is a place of shelter, and "to harbor" is also a verb for keeping something hidden, the way people harbor a secret or a grudge. In four lines, the poem asks which kind of harbor the speaker has become.

The epigraph sets the terms: «Never say the L word.» The guillemets make it read like a rule handed down, though the poem never says whose voice it is. It could be someone else's warning or the speaker's own inner censor. The obvious L word is "love," but the lines that follow make the letter slippery. "Lost" and "loved" are neighbors, sharing an initial, a vowel and a place in the same line, and the speaker treats them as the two options on the table. The first line reworks a familiar saying. "Safe over sorry" drops the "better" and the "than" of "better safe than sorry," so a bit of folk wisdom becomes a policy, a ranking applied without discussion. The second line is the shock. We expect being lost to be the thing a careful person avoids, yet here it beats being loved. "Loved" is passive, and that suggests the speaker is refusing to receive love as much as to give it.

The sound of the poem shifts as it goes. The first two lines are short and tightly packed, with the chiming s of "Safe over sorry" and the l of "Lost over loved," and a semicolon that holds them like a pair of scales. There is no true end rhyme anywhere, only faint echoes, such as the long a shared by "safe" and "make." The third line stretches out, and its comma after "choices" creates an awkward hitch, as though the speaker pauses before admitting something. "I've had to make" is the only place the speaker appears, and the phrase describes necessity, not freedom. These are choices that feel forced, and the tired, flat rhythm fits that.

The final line is by far the longest. It runs on without a pause, the way a person talks when explaining themselves a little too thoroughly. It opens with "Because," so the poem ends on a justification, and it turns on a comparison where the word "easier" matters. The speaker doesn't say it is wiser or happier to catch rain in a cup, only easier. A cup is a made object, a small harbor of its own. Rain caught in it is contained and measurable, and you can watch it from a distance. Rain on the tongue means tipping your head back, opening your mouth and standing out in the weather. It is also hard to do well, since the rain is random and most of it misses.

The image doubles back on the poem in a second way. "On the tip of your tongue" is the idiom for a word you almost say but can't, so the rain on the tongue is also the unspoken word from the epigraph. There is a quieter echo in the vowels. "Loved," "cup" and "tongue" all share the same short u sound, so the word the speaker won't say turns up inside both the vessel and the mouth. The pronoun shifts too, from "I've" to "your." A private fear becomes a general law, and the speaker seems to invite the reader to agree that anyone would choose the cup.

Even the poem's one rule is bent. "Loved" appears in the text, but only as the rejected option, tucked into the past tense and kept at arm's length. The poem handles love the way its speaker does, naming it only to turn it down.

What makes the poem worth studying is how much it fits into so little space. Its argument moves from slogan to admission to image, and each step sounds reasonable. "Safe," "easier" and "a cup" are all sensible words. Added together, they describe a life arranged so that nothing can get in. The poem doesn't say whether the speaker is content with that, and the reader has to decide whether a cup of rain is enough.

Read also

More by Harbor

All poems
ContemplativeHarbor

The trick is to not hate being Alone

In my misconceived notion of what boxes to tick, And when to consider myself fulfilled, I slipped into the farce that alone is undesirable; Alone just means more time for me.
InspiredHarbor

leaching

I am dislodging your lies, like leeches off my skin, Replacing them with the soothing balm of my truth.
RomanticHarbor

When you Offer me your Love

When you offer me your love, Do not offer it halfway and insist I see the glass half full, I am not a reservoir. Do not tell me to walk on coals to meet you;