Ceramic Vase — Poem analysis

Jack FrostJuly 28, 2013Sad

I'm sorry my dear love... I just can't choose a decision... I'm not ready to uplift your name... I must let go of our chronicles... But your fragile ceramic skin... Just so plain and so breakable... I can't stand watching you being tormented... Shattering down all the things you enjoy the most... But I'm just not inexplicably ready... Nor sure of my compassionate decisions... There's one thing that's pulling me away... Love it is, but so uncertain, so faded to perceive... I don't want to pick up the shattered pieces I made... Because it's nearly impossible... For me to salvage without getting hurt... It's just so hard to let go... But I have chosen the decision... I will let go, just wait and see... I just hope I'm strong enough to glue it back... But it's impossible to make it look like before... I will do it... Just wait and see... I'm certain I'm buying a new vase... Stronger that'll last and I'll love better...

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Every line of "Ceramic Vase" ends in an ellipsis, and that small mark does much of the poem's emotional work. Nobody in these twenty-four lines finishes a thought cleanly. Each sentence trails off, as if the speaker is testing the next one for safety before stepping onto it. Dated July 28, 2013, the poem is a single unbroken block addressed to "my dear love," and it circles a breakup the speaker can neither commit to nor escape.

The governing image arrives halfway through the opening movement: "your fragile ceramic skin... / Just so plain and so breakable." The beloved becomes a vase, and the word "skin" lets body and object merge. At first the tone is tender, even protective: "I can't stand watching you being tormented." But the metaphor slowly turns against the speaker. By line thirteen they confess to "the shattered pieces I made," so the damage is their own, yet the next breath is about self-protection. Picking them up is "nearly impossible / For me to salvage without getting hurt." Pity gives way to self-interest, and the sharpest edges in the poem belong to that admission.

The diction is unusual and worth slowing down for. The speaker says "I just can't choose a decision" and later "I have chosen the decision," and the clumsy repetition of that noun makes the decision feel like an object they keep picking up and putting down. Phrases such as "uplift your name," "our chronicles," and "not inexplicably ready" reach for a formal, dignified register, though they sit a little off-balance. Whether or not that is deliberate, the effect suits a speaker who cannot say the plain thing plainly. The word "just" recurs again and again ("just can't," "just so plain," "just so hard," "just hope," "just wait and see"). Each time it shrinks the feeling it modifies, as though the pain could be made smaller by talking about it lightly.

Structurally, this is free verse with no rhyme scheme and no regular meter. The lines are long and prose-like, close in length, and each is end-stopped by its ellipsis, so there is no enjambment to carry the reader forward. The poem moves by hesitation, not momentum. Repetition does the work rhyme might have done: "decision" and "decisions," "impossible" twice, and the refrain "just wait and see," which appears twice. That refrain is ambiguous. It could be a promise to the lover, or the speaker bargaining with themselves, and since each repetition postpones the act it promises, it sounds more like stalling.

The ending is where the poem becomes quietly unsettling. The speaker hopes to "glue it back," then concedes that it can't "look like before," then announces, "I'm certain I'm buying a new vase." After a poem soaked in uncertainty, the word "certain" appears only at the moment the loved one becomes replaceable. The last line, "Stronger that'll last and I'll love better," is grammatically knotted, but its logic is clear enough. The next vase will be sturdier, and the speaker's love will improve. The fragility is filed as the beloved's flaw, even though two lines earlier the speaker admitted making the pieces.

That tension is what makes the poem worth reading. Judging by the text, it may be a sincere attempt to mourn a relationship. Yet the extended metaphor exposes more than the speaker seems to intend, because it turns a person into an object and a heartbreak into a purchase. Students can take from it a useful lesson about how one sustained image can carry love and its betrayal at once, and how punctuation alone, a row of repeated dots, can set a poem's rhythm and mood. The poem's real subject is the stories we tell ourselves in order to leave.

Read also

More by Jack Frost

All poems
RomanticJack Frost

Snowflake

In the fault line where my vunerability gives to take Where no crevice is left as my remedy Will you be my snowflake... And fall for me ?
DreamyJack Frost

Temptation of the Moon

You grow enthusiastically depressed over being loveless The moonlight kissing my skin under the purple skies My vision faded from red to an igneous blue An indefinite color with such a hue
ContemplativeJack Frost

Wings of Water's Seasons

And then you start falling with the snow... Captured by its wings of endless purity... But at the end of all the intrigued memories... You will always find yourself to melt...